Sierra Sleep Limited Edition 12 Inch Plush Mattress by Ashley vs SomosBeds Mayfield Plush Mattress

Buy the Sierra Sleep if you want a thick, tall plush bed with a long non-prorated warranty and a large base of owner ratings behind it. Buy the SomosBeds Mayfield if you want a lower-profile plush innerspring with a cool gel foam top and a 100-night trial. The Sierra Sleep is the more substantial build: 12 inches of foam over wrapped coils, a 10-year non-prorated warranty and a 4.9 average from 270 ratings. The Mayfield is thinner at 9.5 inches, has a 7-year limited warranty and only 50 ratings at 4.6, but its gel foam sleeps cooler and the trial lets you test it at home.

• Choose the Sierra Sleep if you want a tall, supportive plush mattress with a 10-year non-prorated warranty and a long track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the SomosBeds Mayfield if you want a lower-profile plush innerspring with cooling gel foam and a 100-night home trial.