Signature Hardware Elmdale 30" Vanity vs Home Decorators Collection Beaufort 30 in. Vanity

Both are 30-inch freestanding single-sink vanities with a top and undermount sink included, so the choice comes down to finish and storage layout. The Signature Hardware Elmdale pairs a white cabinet with a Carrara marble top and adds a drawer with soft-close slides and soft-close hinges, which suits buyers who want a classic stone look and a drawer for small items. The Home Decorators Collection Beaufort uses an engineered stone top with a matching backsplash and a double-door cabinet with one adjustable shelf, which suits buyers who want more flexible shelf storage and a darker, modern finish. Owners of both report the tops and sinks hold up well; the main complaints on this class of vanity are drawer and door alignment and the lack of a backsplash on the Elmdale.

• Choose the Signature Hardware Elmdale if you want a real Carrara marble top, a drawer with soft-close slides, and a white cabinet that fits a traditional or transitional bathroom.
• Choose the Home Decorators Collection Beaufort if you want an adjustable shelf behind two doors, a matching backsplash in the box, and a darker modern finish with brushed hardware.