Which is better for a party?

The SLUSHi XL, because its 96 oz max fill makes bigger batches than the Ninja's 64 oz. The Ninja is easier to clean between rounds.

Does either need ice?

No. Both freeze the liquid themselves with a compressor, so you pour in a drink and let the machine work.

Which is easier to clean?

The Ninja. Its parts are dishwasher safe and it has a rinse cycle. The SLUSHi XL lists removable parts but no dishwasher claim.

How long do drinks stay frozen?

Both hold frozen texture for up to 12 hours.

Is the SLUSHi XL worth stepping up to?

Only if batch size matters most. The Ninja has more presets tuned to specific drinks and a much larger record of owner feedback.

Which has more settings?

The SLUSHi XL, with six programs and 15 temperature settings versus the Ninja's five presets plus a thickness control.

SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker vs Ninja SLUSHi

The Ninja SLUSHi is the safer pick for most homes: it has a large, well-documented owner base, five drink presets, dishwasher-safe parts and a rinse cycle, and reviewers consistently praise the texture and easy cleanup. The SLUSHi XL is the choice only if batch size is the priority, since its tank and fill capacity are bigger and it offers more temperature settings. Ninja wins on proven reliability and cleaning convenience; the XL wins on volume.

Choose the SLUSHi XL if you regularly make frozen drinks for a crowd and want the largest batch and the most temperature settings.
Choose the Ninja SLUSHi if you want a proven machine with drink-specific presets, dishwasher-safe parts and strong owner reviews.

Prices

SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker: $261.99 at REBEL (checked today)
Ninja SLUSHi: $333.99 at TheTrendlyy (checked today)
Difference: the SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker is $72.00 cheaper than the Ninja SLUSHi today

SLUSHi XL 128oz Smart Frozen Drink Maker

	SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker	Ninja SLUSHi
Tank capacity	128 oz tank, 96 oz max fill	88 oz vessel, 64 oz max fill
Presets	6 programs	5 presets: Slush, Spiked Slush, Frappé, Milkshake, Frozen Juice
Temperature settings	15 settings	Adjustable control for thicker or thinner output
Cleaning	Removable parts; no dishwasher claim given	Rinse cycle and removable dishwasher-safe parts
Owner feedback	Limited review base	4.4 out of 5 from about 2,300 ratings
Freeze technology	Compressor-based freezing, no ice needed	RapidChill compressor, no ice needed
Texture hold	Up to 12 hours	Up to 12 hours
Footprint and weight	About 31.5 lb	About 29.7 lb, 20.6 x 9.8 x 22.5 in

Spec	SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker	Ninja SLUSHi
Capacity	1 gal tank capacity	88 oz
Weight	14,3 kg	29.74 lbs
Warranty	1	1
Max liquid fill	96-oz	—
Programs	6 Programs	—
Temperature settings	15 Temperature Control Settings	—
Texture hold	up to 12 hours	—
Max Fill	—	64 oz
Preset Programs	—	5
Wattage	—	200 watts
Voltage	—	120 volts
Amperage	—	2.4 amps

Spec	SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker	Ninja SLUSHi
Cord Length	—	60 in
Dishwasher Safe	—	Yes
Color	—	Artic Blue and Gray
Frozen drink maker type	—	Slush Drink Makers
Volume capacity	—	96 fl oz
Brand	—	Ninja
Features	—	Dishwasher Safe Parts
Number of tanks	—	1
Speeds	—	5
Dimensions	—

SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker vs Ninja SLUSHi

Prices

SLUSHi XL Smart Frozen Drink Maker vs Ninja SLUSHi

Prices

Ninja SLUSHi

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store