Which is better for snow and rain?

The Sorel. It is waterproof with a rubber outsole and fleece lining, while the Dr. Martens is plain leather with no waterproof claim.

The Sorel. Its fleece and shearling lining is made for cold weather; the Dr. Martens is unlined leather.

Both use genuine leather. The Dr. Martens lace-up is easier to re-lace and resole at a cobbler; the Sorel's rubber outsole resists wet wear better.

Is the Dr. Martens worth the extra $11?

Only if you want the Powerpuff Girls print and a lace-up for dry weather. For winter use the cheaper Sorel does more.

Can I wear the Dr. Martens in summer?

Yes. It is listed for all four seasons, while the Sorel is listed for fall and winter only.

Which fits wider calves?

Both are medium width. The Sorel's tall shaft is the tighter constraint; the Dr. Martens ankle height fits more calves without adjustment.

Sorel Ona Ave Alpine LX Tall Boots vs Dr. Martens Buzz 5i Powerpuff Girls Boot

Buy the Sorel Ona Ave Alpine LX if you need a winter boot that handles snow and wet weather. Its waterproof leather, fleece lining and rubber outsole are built for cold, slushy streets. Buy the Dr. Martens Buzz 5i Powerpuff Girls if you want a leather lace-up with a cartoon print for dry, everyday wear. The Sorel is $159 at Distritech as of November 3; the Dr. Martens is $170 at Zappos as of November 3, so the Sorel is cheaper and more weather-ready.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.