Which is better for snow and cold?

The St. John's Bay. Its 10-inch shaft and lace-up fit cover more of the leg and stay put in slush. The SO Lupita is a 3-inch ankle boot for dry, mild days.

Is the SO Lupita worth the savings?

At $11.99 at Kohl's as of November 7, 2026, it costs about half the St. John's Bay's $24.00 at ModeSens. It is a good buy if you only need a cozy slip-on, not a snow boot.

Do the SO Lupita boots run small?

Some Kohl's buyers say they run small. Size up if you wear thick socks or are between sizes.

Which has the taller shaft?

The St. John's Bay, at 10 inches versus 3 inches for the SO Lupita. That is the biggest practical difference between them.

Which is easier to put on?

The SO Lupita. It is pull-on with no laces. The St. John's Bay laces up, which takes longer but gives a tighter, adjustable fit.

Are either waterproof?

Neither is listed as waterproof. The St. John's Bay has a fabric upper and the SO has a microfiber upper, so treat both as water-resistant at best.

St. John's Bay Faux Fur-Lined Winter Boots vs SO Lupita Micro Mini Ankle Boots

These are not really the same kind of boot. The St. John's Bay is a 10-inch lace-up winter boot with a 16-inch shaft, built for cold and snow. The SO Lupita is a 3-inch pull-on ankle boot for dry, mild days. At $11.99 at Kohl's as of November 7, 2026, the SO is far cheaper than the St. John's Bay at $24.00 at ModeSens. Buy the St. John's Bay if you need coverage and a secure fit; buy the SO if you want a cheap, cozy slip-on.

Today the SO Lupita Micro Mini Ankle Boots costs $12.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.