Stacy Adams Savian Velour Slip On Loafers vs Rag & Co Maestro Diamante Embellished Horsebit Loafers

The Stacy Adams Savian is the safer pick: a plain-toe velour slip-on with a Memory Foam footbed, breathable linings and a rubber outsole, and it rates 4.7 from 13 owners. The Rag & Co Maestro is the showier choice, with diamante embellishment and a horsebit detail, but it rates 3.5 from 19 ratings, so satisfaction is less consistent. Buy the Savian for all-day wear and the Maestro for a statement look.

• Choose the Stacy Adams Savian if you want a cushioned velour loafer you can wear for hours and a plain toe that stays understated.
• Choose the Rag & Co Maestro if you want a horsebit loafer with diamante sparkle as the focal point of an outfit.