Starter Set vs Skincare Gift Set
Buy the Starter Set for a new baby or anyone with itchy, sensitive skin: it is a goat milk soap, lotion and lip butter gift with a wooden dish, and it has sold as low as $19.95. Buy the Skincare Gift Set for an adult who wants to try a full face routine in mini sizes, especially with the $50 gift card inside. The Starter Set's price history runs from $19.95 to $40.00, so check the current price before you buy.
Ask our shopping agent
Starter Set
4.9Choose the Starter Set if you need a newborn-safe, all-natural bath and body gift for new parents or sensitive skin.
Pros
- Goat milk soap and lotion are aimed at itchy, sensitive and eczema-prone skin.
- Free of sulfates, dyes, parabens, phthalates and PPGs.
- Cruelty-free and made in the USA by a family-owned company.
- Gift-ready packaging with a gift message option.
- Has sold for as little as $19.95.
Cons
- Scented, which some sensitive newborns may not tolerate.
- Only three essentials plus a dish; no dedicated face serum or eye cream.
- Listed price has swung from $19.95 to $40.00, so timing matters.
What separates them
| Starter Set | Skincare Gift Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary user | Newborns and babies with sensitive skin | Adults, unisex |
| What is in the box | Full and travel goat milk soap bars, lotion, lip butter, wood soap dish | Five deluxe minis: two moisturizers, two serums, one eye cream |
| Body area | Bath and body, including face-safe soap | Face only |
| Key ingredients | Goat milk, allantoin; free of sulfates, dyes, parabens, phthalates | Hyaluronic acid, 5% caffeine, EGCG, 7% glycolic acid, 10% niacinamide + 1% zinc |
| Scented | Yes | Not stated as scented |
| Extra value | Gift message included, gift-set packaging | $50 gift card that expires 06/30/27 |
| Price range seen | $19.95 to $40.00 in daily price history | No price given |
| Ratings |
Price history
$40.00$15.00
- Starter Set: lowest $19.95 on Oct 31 at Amazon; $40.00 on Nov 1.
- Skincare Gift Set: lowest $15.00 on Oct 31 at eBay.
Prices at every store
Starter Set
- NordstromCheck price at Nordstrom
- Bend Soap CompanyCheck price at Bend Soap Company
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
Skincare Gift Set
- Fleur & BeeCheck price at Fleur & Bee
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Specs compared
| Spec | Starter Set | Skincare Gift Set |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Users | Newborns, Babies with sensitive skin | Unisex, Adult |
| Occasion | New Baby | — |
| Overall Theme | Bath-time and skincare essentials | — |
| Quantity | 3 | — |
| Free Of | Sulfates, Dyes, Parabens, Phthalates, PPGs | — |
| Highlighted Ingredients | Allantoin | — |
| Maximum Age | KIDS | — |
| Minimum Age | Newborns | — |
| Height | 7.8125" (packaging) | — |
| Weight | 24 OZ | — |
| Width |
Questions and answers
- Which set is better for a newborn?
- The Starter Set. It is made for newborns and babies with sensitive skin, with goat milk soap and lotion. The Skincare Gift Set is for adult faces and includes acids and caffeine.
- Which is better for eczema-prone skin?
- The Starter Set. Buyers report it helped itchy, sensitive skin within days, and it is free of sulfates, dyes and parabens. The Skincare Gift Set's glycolic acid toner can sting broken or irritated skin.
- Is the Skincare Gift Set worth it for the gift card alone?
- The $50 gift card is a real bonus, but it expires 06/30/27 and likely has minimum-spend terms. Treat the five minis as the main value and the card as extra.
- Which one lasts longer?
- The Starter Set. Full-size soap, lotion and lip butter outlast five deluxe minis, and the 15 ml niacinamide serum runs out quickly with daily use.
- Can I use the Starter Set on an adult face?
- Yes. The goat milk soap and lotion are gentle enough for adult sensitive skin, though the set has no serum or eye cream.
- Which has better ratings?
- The Starter Set, at 4.9 out of 5 from 525 ratings versus 4.8 out of 5 from 217 for the Skincare Gift Set. Both are high.
