Stetson Elmhurst Straw Cowboy Hat vs Stetson White Horse Straw Cowboy Hat
Both are Stetson straw cowboy hats with a cattleman crease, so the choice comes down to brim width, sweatband and trim. The Elmhurst gives you a wider 4 1/4" brim for more sun coverage and a leather band with buckle, while the White Horse uses denser Bangora straw, a Dri-Lex sweatband and a studded band. Buyers who work outside all day tend to favor the White Horse's sweatband and tighter weave; buyers who want a cleaner, dressier look lean to the Elmhurst. Neither is a rugged felt hat, so expect a seasonal lifespan from both.
- Choose the Elmhurst if you want the wider brim for sun coverage and a plain leather band that dresses up easily.
- Choose the White Horse if you want denser Bangora straw, a Dri-Lex sweatband for sweat management and a studded band with more flash.
Prices
- Stetson Elmhurst Straw Cowboy Hat: $34.99 at eBay (checked today)
- Stetson White Horse Straw Cowboy Hat: $44.99 at The Boot Jack (checked today)
- Difference: the Stetson Elmhurst Straw Cowboy Hat is $10.00 cheaper than the Stetson White Horse Straw Cowboy Hat today

