StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats vs PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats

Both are single-ingredient freeze-dried treats, so the real choice comes down to protein and format. The Stewart Pro-Treat is beef liver in a resealable 4 oz tub, which suits daily training and toy stuffing; owners rate it 4.5 from 163 ratings and like the tub for freshness. The Purebites Wild Smelt is a 2.1 oz bag of whole wild-caught fish, rated 4.8 from 95 ratings, and is the better pick for dogs with beef or poultry sensitivities or for use as a topper. Neither is a complete diet; both are treats.

  • Choose the Stewart Pro-Treat if you want a larger resealable tub of beef liver for frequent training, stuffing chew toys, or feeding both dogs and cats.
  • Choose the Purebites Wild Smelt if your dog needs a novel fish protein, a very lean low-calorie reward, or a RAW-style topper.

Prices

  • Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats: $16.99 at Walmart (checked today)
  • PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats: $12.99 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Difference: the PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats is $4.00 cheaper than the Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats today
Stewart
Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

4.5(163 ratings)
$16.99at WalmartChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Single ingredient: beef liver only
  • Resealable 4 oz tub keeps treats fresh
  • About 4 kcal per treat, easy to portion for training
  • Grain-free and gluten-free with no corn, soy or artificial flavor
  • Works for both dogs and cats
Cons
  • Beef liver is a common allergen for sensitive dogs
  • Strong liver smell some owners dislike
  • Morsels can crumble and leave residue in the tub
Purebites
Purebites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats 2.1 oz.

PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats

Purebites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats 2.1 oz.

4.8(95 ratings)
$12.99at WalmartChecked 2 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Single ingredient: 100% wild-caught smelt
  • Novel fish protein suits elimination diets
  • High protein and low calorie
  • Freeze-dried RAW style, no refrigeration needed
  • Highest owner rating of the two
Cons
  • Smaller 2.1 oz bag empties faster
  • Whole fish are awkward for small dogs and quick training reps
  • Strong fish odor
  • Dogs only, not cats

What separates them

Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog TreatsPureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats
Protein sourceBeef liver, a single organ meatWhole wild-caught smelt, a novel fish protein
Pack format4 oz resealable tub that keeps morsels fresh2.1 oz resealable bag
Treat sizeSmall morsels, about 4 kcal each, easy to break for trainingWhole small fish, larger and fishier, better torn than popped whole
Allergen profileBeef liver; not suitable for dogs with beef sensitivityFish only; a good option for beef or poultry elimination diets
SpeciesMarketed for dogs and catsDogs only
Texture and smellDense liver pieces with a strong liver odorCrisp whole fish with a strong fish odor
Use as a topperCan be crumbled over food, especially at the end of the tubDesigned as a high-value topper and RAW-diet complement
Owner ratings4.5 from 163 ratings4.8 from 95 ratings

Price history

$12.99$5.69
Nov 9Nov 16
  • Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats: lowest $5.69 on Nov 16 at Amazon.
  • PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats: lowest $12.99 on Nov 9 at Chewy; $12.99 on Nov 16.

Prices at every store

Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by DarAlTamayezLLCReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $16.99+ $5.99 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Walmart

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • ChewyCheck price at Chewy
  • DoorDashCheck price at DoorDash

Store links may earn us a commission.

Prices and history →

PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by Pure TreatsReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $12.99Checked 2 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • ChewyNew

    In stock

    $12.99+ $4.95 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Chewy
  • PetcoNew

    In stock

    $12.99+ $6.99 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Petco
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $12.99Checked 2 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecStewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog TreatsPureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats
size4 oz2.1 oz
Flavor| Beef liver—
First ingredient| Beef liver—
Calories per treat| 4 kcal—
Grain FreeYes—
TypeTreat—
Health BenefitAllergy Control—
shape4 oz—
colorMulticolor—
Food Type—Treats
Weight/pack. (oz)—2.1
Packaging—Bag
Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
SpecStewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog TreatsPureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats
Age Group—Adult

What reviewers say

Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

  • 4.5 / 5163 ratings

Owners rate these highly as training treats because dogs go for the strong liver smell. Some mention the crumbly texture and the odor.

What people mention
  • TastePraisedOwners say dogs are eager for these treats and respond well in training.
  • TextureCriticisedReviewers note the pieces are dry and crumbly, leaving dust in the bag.
  • SmellMixedThe strong liver odor appeals to dogs but some owners find it unpleasant.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers like that beef liver is the only ingredient and that the treats are grain free.

PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats

  • 4.8 / 595 ratings

Owners of picky and allergy-prone dogs tend to rate these highly, saying the fish smell gets even reluctant eaters interested and that the short ingredient list is easy on sensitive stomachs. The common complaints are the strong odor, the small bag and how easily the fish break apart.

What people mention
  • SmellMixedOwners say the fish odor is strong but is exactly what draws their dogs to the treat.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers like that the only ingredient is wild smelt, which helps with dogs on elimination diets.
  • Bag sizeCriticisedReviewers note the bag is small and empties quickly with medium and large dogs.
  • TextureMixed

Questions and answers

Which is better for a dog with food allergies?
Purebites Wild Smelt, if the allergy is to beef or poultry. It is a single fish protein, so it fits an elimination diet. If your dog reacts to fish, the beef liver Stewart is the alternative, but beef is itself a common trigger.
Which lasts longer?
The Stewart tub holds 4 oz against Purebites' 2.1 oz, so it lasts roughly twice as long at the same feeding rate. Both are freeze-dried and shelf-stable; the tub reseals more securely for long storage.
Are these complete meals or just treats?
Treats. Neither is formulated as a complete diet. Use them for training, rewards or as a topper, and keep them to a small share of daily calories.
Which is better for training a puppy?
Stewart. The small morsels break easily into tiny pieces and the tub keeps them fresh through long sessions. Purebites whole smelt are larger and harder to portion quickly.
Is the Purebites worth stepping up to over the Stewart?
Only if you need a fish protein or a leaner topper. The Stewart gives you more volume and a better container; the Purebites gives you a novel protein and a slightly higher owner rating.
Can cats eat these?
Stewart markets its treats for dogs and cats. Purebites Wild Smelt is sold for dogs. Check with your vet before feeding either to a cat as more than an occasional treat.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats vs Pupford Freeze-dried Training Treats
  • Purebites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats 2.1 oz. vs Pupford Freeze-dried Training Treats
  • Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats vs Freeze-Dried Salmon Bites Dog Treats
  • Purebites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats 2.1 oz. vs Freeze-Dried Salmon Bites Dog Treats

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best freeze dried dog treats
The freeze-dried fish are light and break apart easily, which some find handy for toppers and others find messy.