Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats vs PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats
Both are single-ingredient freeze-dried treats, so the real choice comes down to protein and format. The Stewart Pro-Treat is beef liver in a resealable 4 oz tub, which suits daily training and toy stuffing; owners rate it 4.5 from 163 ratings and like the tub for freshness. The Purebites Wild Smelt is a 2.1 oz bag of whole wild-caught fish, rated 4.8 from 95 ratings, and is the better pick for dogs with beef or poultry sensitivities or for use as a topper. Neither is a complete diet; both are treats.
- Choose the Stewart Pro-Treat if you want a larger resealable tub of beef liver for frequent training, stuffing chew toys, or feeding both dogs and cats.
- Choose the Purebites Wild Smelt if your dog needs a novel fish protein, a very lean low-calorie reward, or a RAW-style topper.
Prices
- Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats: $16.99 at Walmart (checked today)
- PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats: $12.99 at Walmart (checked today)
- Difference: the PureBites Wild Smelt Freeze Dried Dog Treats is $4.00 cheaper than the Stewart Pro-Treat Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Dog Treats today

