Which is better for everyday wear?

The Stone Pendant Necklace. Its 18k gold plating over stainless steel and brass is listed as rust- and tarnish-resistant, and the 18" chain with a 2" extender fits more necks. The Butterfly is also sold as an everyday piece, but one reviewer found its chain short.

Which has the better stones?

The Butterfly Pendant uses mother-of-pearl and abalone with cubic zirconia accents, which give visible color and shine. The Stone Pendant's semi-precious stone is clear but not named, so you know less about what you get.

The Stone Pendant has the edge on paper: 18k gold plating over stainless steel and brass, rated tarnish- and rust-resistant. The Butterfly is gold over brass with dyed shell, and its metal listing is inconsistent, so treat it as the more delicate piece.

Is the Butterfly worth it over the Stone Pendant?

If you want a decorative butterfly with shell color, yes. If you want a larger, simpler pendant with a longer adjustable chain and a higher rating, the Stone Pendant is the safer pick.

Which is better as a gift?

Both ship in a premium gift box. The Stone Pendant's 4.8 rating and plain design suit most tastes; the Butterfly is more of a statement and fits birthday or Valentine's gifting.

Which pendant is bigger?

The Stone Pendant at 38.1mm with a 1.5" drop. The Butterfly is about 11.9mm wide and 13mm tall, so it sits much smaller on the neck.

Stone Pendant Necklace vs Butterfly Pendant Necklace

Buy the Stone Pendant Necklace for a larger, plainer everyday piece with an 18k gold plated finish and a 2-inch extender. Buy the Butterfly Pendant Necklace for a small statement butterfly with mother-of-pearl and abalone accents at a lower price. The Stone Pendant has the higher rating (4.8 from 70 ratings) versus 4.6 from 654 ratings for the Butterfly, so the Butterfly's score rests on far more reviews.

Ask our shopping agent