Which set is better for a small living room?

The Cashton. Its sofa is 87 inches wide and its loveseat 63, both shorter than the Stonemeade. Check the 36-inch doorway width for delivery.

The Stonemeade has the edge on paper. Its reversible seat cushions can be flipped to even out wear, and its platform foundation is tested to resist sagging better than springs.

Is the Cashton worth stepping up to?

Only if size matters more than track record. It rates slightly higher but from far fewer owners, and it gives up reversible cushions and the tested platform base.

Which has better owner reviews?

The Cashton scores 4.7 versus 4.5 for the Stonemeade, but from 30 ratings against 144. The Stonemeade's score rests on a much larger sample.

Do both come as a sofa, loveseat and chair?

Yes. The Stonemeade is sold in several configurations including sofa and loveseat, and the Cashton comes as a sofa and loveseat pair or a four-piece set.

Ashley Stonemeade Living Room Set vs Cashton Living Room Set

Buy the Stonemeade if you want a proven set with a large owner base and a platform foundation that resists sagging. Buy the Cashton if you want a more compact footprint and a slightly higher owner rating. The Stonemeade is the safer pick on track record; the Cashton is the tighter fit for smaller rooms.

Choose the Stonemeade if you have the floor space for a 92-inch sofa and want a set with more owner feedback behind it.
Choose the Cashton if your room is tighter and you want a shorter sofa and loveseat with a higher average rating.

Prices

Ashley Stonemeade Living Room Set: $863.83 at BEL Furniture (last seen Nov 9)
Cashton Living Room Set: $464.99 at US Furniture Direct (NC) (last seen Nov 10)
Difference: the Cashton Living Room Set is $398.84 cheaper than the Ashley Stonemeade Living Room Set at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 10)