Strawberry Shortcake Huckleberry Pie Doll vs Funko Pop Retro Huckleberry Pie

These are two very different Huckleberry Pies. The 1979 American Greetings doll is a genuine vintage collectible with real age and scarcity; the Funko Pop #136 is a new, sealed vinyl figure built for display. Buy the vintage doll if you want an original piece of Strawberry Shortcake history and can accept its flaws. Buy the Funko Pop if you want a clean, boxed figure that looks the same on day one and in ten years.

• Choose the 1979 Huckleberry Pie doll if you collect original Strawberry Shortcake memorabilia and want a stamped, era-correct piece even with missing hat, scarf and pet.
• Choose the Funko Pop Huckleberry Pie if you want a new, undamaged figure in its window box with no restoration or condition worries.