Which is better for everyday wear?

The Dr. Martens Adrian. Its leather upper, leather lining and slip-resistant rubber sole hold up to daily use in any season. The raffia Stuart Weitzman is better kept for dry, warm days.

The Dr. Martens Adrian. Leather and a rubber outsole resist wear better than raffia and a flat sole.

Is the Stuart Weitzman worth the extra money?

Only if you want the raffia look and buckle detail. At $121.00 to $210.00 it costs more than the Dr. Martens, which has been seen at $69.97.

Can I wear the Dr. Martens in rain?

Yes, more safely than the raffia loafer. The rubber outsole is slip resistant, though the leather upper still needs care in wet weather.

How do the sizes compare?

The Stuart Weitzman is listed in US 9.5, medium width. The Dr. Martens is listed in UK 4, medium width, so convert to your US size before ordering.

Which is better for summer?

The Stuart Weitzman Owen. Raffia breathes better than leather in heat, and the flat sole suits casual warm-weather wear.

Stuart Weitzman Owen Buckle Loafer vs Dr. Martens Adrian Tassel Loafer

Buy the Dr. Martens Adrian if you want a durable leather loafer with a rubber sole and tassel detail; buy the Stuart Weitzman Owen if you want a light raffia slip-on with a buckle and horsebit accent for warm-weather casual wear. The Dr. Martens has been seen at $69.97 (as of November 3) against a high of $162.00, while the Stuart Weitzman has ranged from $121.00 (November 1) to $210.00 (October 31). On price alone the Dr. Martens is the cheaper pick at its low.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.