Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch vs Casio F-91W
Buy the Casio F-91W if you want a cheap, light, durable everyday watch with an alarm and stopwatch. Buy the Stuhrling if you want an analog leather-strap look for casual wear and accept a quartz watch with a 42mm case. The Casio is $18.95 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, while the Stuhrling's lowest recorded price is $102.00 as of October 28, 2026.
Ask our shopping agent
Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch
3.4Choose the Stuhrling if you want an analog face and a leather strap for casual or dressier outfits.
- Analog look with a leather strap
- Scratch-resistant crystal
- 42mm case suits larger wrists
- Simple quartz movement, no winding
- Rated 3.4 out of 5 from only 5 ratings
- No alarm, stopwatch or light
- Battery life not stated
- Costs about five times the Casio
What separates them
| Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch | Casio F-91W | |
|---|---|---|
| Display | Analog with hands | Digital LCD |
| Case size | 42mm round case | 33mm resin case |
| Weight and profile | Leather strap, larger case | Very slim and light |
| Battery | Quartz movement, battery not specified | About 7 years on CR2016 |
| Extra functions | Time only | Alarm, stopwatch, LED microlight |
| Water resistance | Water resistant, rating not specified | Water resistant |
| Glass | Scratch-resistant | Resin glass |
| Price | $102.00 lowest recorded, as of October 28, 2026 |
Price history
- Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch: lowest $102.00 on Oct 28; $102.00 on Oct 29.
- Casio F-91W: lowest $18.95 on Oct 30 at Amazon; $18.95 on Nov 3.
Prices at every store
Casio F-91W
- eBayNew
In stockSold by qualitywatchbands
$34.94+ $4.95 shippingObserved at 9:03 PM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$18.95Observed at 9:03 PM
Also available at
- Best BuyCheck price at Best Buy
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
Specs compared
| Spec | Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch | Casio F-91W |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Wrist | Wrist |
| Display | Analog | Digital |
| Water Resistant | Yes | Yes |
| Watch Movement | Quartz | — |
| Scratch-Resistant | Yes | — |
| Case Shape | Round Case | — |
| Case Size | 42mm case | — |
| Band material | — | Resin Band |
| Case material | — | Resin |
| Battery life | — | Approx. battery life: 7 years on CR2016 |
| Water resistance |
What reviewers say
Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch
Only a handful of ratings exist, averaging 3.4 out of 5, so the picture is thin. The pattern in Stuhrling's budget quartz line is that buyers like the look for the money but question long-term finish.
- Dressy look at a low price
- Comfortable leather strap out of the box
- Legible analog dial
- Strap shows wear quickly
- Build feels light for the price
- Inconsistent quality between units
Casio F-91W
With 351 ratings averaging 4.1 out of 5, owners treat the F-91W as a reliable, no-frills watch that does what it promises for very little money. The main recurring complaint is timekeeping drift.
- Great value for the price
Questions and answers
- Which is better for everyday wear?
- The Casio F-91W. It is lighter, has a 7-year battery, an alarm and a stopwatch, and costs $18.95 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026.
- Which looks better with a suit?
- The Stuhrling. Its analog face and leather strap read dressier than the Casio's black resin digital design.
- Is the Stuhrling worth about $100?
- Only if you want an analog leather-strap watch. The Casio does more for far less, but it looks casual.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Casio has a documented 7-year battery and a durable resin build. The Stuhrling's battery life is not stated, though its scratch-resistant crystal holds up better than resin glass.
- Which fits a large wrist?
- The Stuhrling, with its 42mm case. The Casio's 33mm case is small and suits smaller wrists.
- Does either have an alarm?
- Only the Casio F-91W. It also has a stopwatch and an LED microlight; the Stuhrling is time-only.
More comparisons
- Tissot PRX Powermatic 80 vs Casio F-91W
- Citizen Eco-Drive Chandler vs Casio F-91W
- Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch vs Tissot PRX Powermatic 80
- Stuhrling Men's Original Quartz Leather Strap Watch vs Citizen Eco-Drive Chandler
- Casio F-91W vs Casio A158WA
- Casio F-91W vs SKMEI Men's Digital Sports Watch
- Casio F-91W vs Invicta Pro Diver Men's Watch