Which is better for everyday wear?

The Airman 4078. It is cheaper, better rated and its pilot dial is easy to read. The Statesman's buyers report crystal and dial problems with regular use.

Is the Statesman worth $20 more?

Only if you want the two-tone dress look, the fluted bezel and 100M water resistance. On reliability and rating, the Airman is the safer buy.

Which has better water resistance?

The Statesman 4070 at 100M versus 50M for the Airman. The Statesman handles swimming; the Airman is fine for splashes and rain.

The Statesman's stainless steel case should outlast the Airman's alloy case, but buyer reports of cracked crystals and detached dials undercut that. The Airman has the better rating record.

Do either have GPS or smart features?

No. Both are analog quartz watches with no GPS, touchscreen or app support.

Which is the better gift?

The Airman 4078. It costs less, has the higher rating and a clean pilot look. The Statesman suits someone who wants a dressier two-tone watch.

Stührling Statesman 4070 Men's Watch vs Stührling Airman 4078 Pilot Watch

Buy the Airman 4078 if you want a reliable everyday quartz watch at the lower price. Buy the Statesman 4070 if you want a dressier two-tone look with a fluted bezel and day-date. The Airman is $109 at Macy's as of November 6, 2026, and the Statesman is $129 at Macy's the same day. The Airman has the stronger rating (4.9 from 70 versus 4.0 from 31) and more store coverage.

Today the Stührling Airman 4078 Pilot Watch costs $20.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.