Style & Co Cotton Scoop-Neck Top vs Style & Co Cotton Henley Top

Both are Style & Co all-cotton tees with a similar feel, so the choice comes down to neckline and styling. The scoop-neck is the safer everyday basic: a plain crew-alternative that layers well and draws fewer complaints about fading or a shifting neckline. The Henley adds a buttoned split neck and a longer tunic-ish length, which suits casual, slightly dressed-up looks, but owners more often report fading after one wash, a wonky neckline and thin white fabric. Buy the scoop for a durable basic; buy the Henley if you want the button detail and longer cut.

• Choose the Style & Co scoop-neck top if you want a simple, versatile cotton tee that layers easily and holds up as a basic.
• Choose the Style & Co Henley top if you prefer a buttoned split neckline and a longer length for a more styled casual look.