Suspender Store Solid Color Suspenders vs Button and Clip Suspenders

Both are Y-back elastic suspenders with leather trim and dual clip-or-button attachment, so the real choice comes down to sizing and color range. The SuspenderStore pair comes in three adult lengths, including a 54-inch size for taller wearers, and its leather button ends are built in. The 18-color pair is one 48-inch length with six loose buttons you sew on yourself, which suits average-height wearers who want a specific color. Owners of Y-back elastic suspenders generally report the leather crosspatch and adjusters outlast the clips, so check the clip hardware first on either.

• Choose the SuspenderStore Solid Color if you are taller than about 6'1" and need the 54-inch length, or want leather button ends already attached.
• Choose the Button and Clip pair if you are of average height, want a specific color from a wide range, or need to switch between clips and buttons on pants without suspender buttons.