Brown Sugar Babe Sweetest Taboo vs Brown Sugar Babe Diced Pineapples

Both are scented Brown Sugar Babe body oils made in the USA with cold-compressed oils and no parabens or phthalates. Sweetest Taboo is the richer gourmand: caramel, coconut and pineapple up top over raspberry, almond and vanilla, with tonka, musk and heliotrope underneath, and owners describe it as a near-dupe of a known perfume. Diced Pineapples is brighter and more fruit-forward, pineapple and peach over passionfruit, coconut, lemongrass and mango, and its reviewers call it a summer scent that absorbs without grease. Ratings are close (4.7 from 116 versus 4.6 from 144), so pick by scent mood rather than quality.

• Choose the Sweetest Taboo if you want a deep, sweet gourmand that smells like a known perfume and lingers all day.
• Choose the Diced Pineapples if you want a lighter, tropical fruit scent that sinks in without a greasy feel.