Talonwood Table Lamp vs Charlton Home Donohue Table Lamp

The Talonwood is the smaller, warmer piece: a walnut-and-metal base with a fabric shade, about 17 inches tall, and a 40W cap that suits a bedside or reading nook. The Charlton Home Donohue is the bigger, brighter lamp at 28 inches and 100W, so it carries a living room or a large desk better. Owners rate the Talonwood higher on the smaller sample, praising easy assembly and the look; the Donohue has far more ratings and a solid but lower average. Pick by size and light output first, style second.

• Choose the Talonwood if you want a compact, warm-toned lamp for a nightstand or shelf and prefer a wood-and-fabric look with a choice of beige or green shade.
• Choose the Charlton Home Donohue if you need a tall lamp that throws more light across a living room, entry or large desk and want a simple metal body in cream.