Terra & Sky Women's Plus High Rise Skinny Jeans vs Style & Co Women's Plus Size High-Rise Natural Straight-Leg Jeans

Buy the Terra & Sky if you want a curve-hugging skinny leg and a high waist that stays put. Buy the Style & Co if you want a straighter, more relaxed leg that reads as classic denim. The Style & Co has far more owner feedback, about 1,700 ratings at 4 out of 5, so its fit is better documented; the Terra & Sky sits at 4.5 from 37 ratings. Both are cotton-blend stretch denim with a high rise and pockets, so the real split is leg shape and how much give you want.

• Choose the Terra & Sky if you want a skinny leg, a high waist and a stretchy cotton blend with some recycled content.
• Choose the Style & Co if you want a straight leg with a touch of stretch and a track record backed by far more owner ratings.