Everlane The City Boot vs Everlane Chelsea Boot

The Chelsea Boot is the safer pick for most shoppers. Its elastic side panels go on and off faster than the City Boot's interior zip, and the cushioned insole and contrast rubber outsole suit daily wear better. The City Boot has the cleaner, more minimal profile and a lower 45mm block heel, which is steadier for long office days. Owners of Everlane leather boots generally praise the soft nappa uppers but report that the leather creases and scuffs with regular wear; the City Boot's 3.3 out of 5 from 60 ratings reflects some of that.

• Choose the City Boot if you want a sleek, minimal black ankle boot with a low block heel and a zip you can pull on without stretching elastic.
• Choose the Chelsea Boot if you want the classic slip-on Chelsea shape with elastic side panels, a cushioned insole and a rubber outsole built for daily wear.