Jones Road The Face Pencil vs Chantecaille Le Camouflage Stylo

The Face Pencil is the better pick for most shoppers: 25 shades, a creamy buildable formula with shea butter, and a pencil that suits spot touch-ups. Le Camouflage Stylo is a French-made click-pen with a brush tip and a crease-free, fragrance-free formula aimed at under-eye circles and fine lines. Owners rate the Stylo slightly higher, but on far fewer ratings. Choose the Jones Road for shade matching and everyday blemish work; choose the Chantecaille for a precise pen and a polished under-eye finish.

• Choose the Face Pencil if you want a wide shade range, a creamy buildable concealer for blemishes and redness, and a pencil you can carry for touch-ups.
• Choose Le Camouflage Stylo if you want a brush-tip pen for targeted under-eye coverage with a crease-free, fragrance-free finish made in France.