Which is better for a small apartment?

Both are pencil trees, so either fits a tight corner. The Vickerman states its size, 4.5 ft tall and 24 in wide, so you can check the space before buying. The Holiday Aisle listing does not state height or width.

Which has more lights?

The Holiday Aisle Salem has 300 LEDs. The Vickerman has 200 Italian LEDs. More lights means a brighter tree, but the Holiday Aisle's are color changing rather than fixed multi color.

Is the Vickerman worth the savings?

It costs $149.99 at Target versus $159.99 at Wayfair for the Holiday Aisle, so you save $10. You also get a stated 4.5 ft size, 217 tips and a metal stand. You give up the white color and the color-changing lights.

Do either come with a stand?

The Vickerman description says it comes with a metal tree stand. The Holiday Aisle listing does not state whether a stand is included, so confirm before ordering.

Neither listing gives a warranty. The Vickerman uses PVC tips on metal hinged branches, which store and reshape well season to season. The Holiday Aisle gives no tip or branch material details.

Can I get the Holiday Aisle tree anywhere else?

Only 1 store prices it new, Wayfair, at $159.99 as of November 8, 2026. The Vickerman is priced new at 5 stores, so compare those before buying.

The Holiday Aisle Salem Pencil Tree vs Vickerman Salem Pencil Pine Tree

Buy the Vickerman if you want a 4.5-foot green pencil pine with 200 LED lights and a metal stand for $149.99 at Target as of November 8, 2026. Buy The Holiday Aisle Salem if you want a white tree with 300 color-changing LEDs for $159.99 at Wayfair as of November 8, 2026. The Vickerman is $10 cheaper and sold at 5 stores; the Holiday Aisle tree is the only white color-changing option here.

Today the Vickerman Salem Pencil Pine Tree costs $10.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.