The Indulgence Gift Set vs Bath & Body Works Gift Set
The Bath & Body Works Gift Set is the safer pick for a scented, ready-to-give gift, and it costs far less. The Indulgence Gift Set is the better choice for anyone with sensitive skin, eczema, or nut and gluten allergies, since it is all-natural goat milk care. The Indulgence set also has a 50-box minimum order, so it is not a one-off purchase.
Ask our shopping agent
The Indulgence Gift Set
4.9Choose the Indulgence Gift Set if you are buying in bulk for a group, a wedding, or corporate gifting, or the recipient has sensitive skin and needs fragrance-light goat milk soap, lotion, and bath products.
Pros
- 4.9 out of 5 from 525 ratings
- Full wash-to-moisturize routine in one box
- Reported to calm itchy, sensitive skin within days
- Free greeting card and choice of box or tin
- Made in the USA by a family-owned company
Cons
- 50-box minimum order
- No price shown in the listing
- Larger and heavier to ship than a single gift bag
What separates them
| The Indulgence Gift Set | Bath & Body Works Gift Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Not stated in the listing shown | $22.00 low to $28.00 high since October 31, 2026 |
| Minimum order | 50 boxes | Single set |
| Contents | 2 full-size and 1 travel goat milk soap bars, lotion, bath, scrub, lip butter, wood dish, loofah bag, lotion pump | Body cream 8 oz, fragrance mist 8 fl oz, candle 14.5 oz, Wallflowers refill 0.8 fl oz, hand sanitizer 1 fl oz |
| Scent | Unscented to lightly scented goat milk care | Sparkling berries, champagne, tangerine; strongly scented |
| Skin suitability | Marketed for eczema, sensitive skin, and nut and gluten allergies | Fragranced body care; not positioned for sensitive skin |
| Packaging | Keepsake ivory box or silver tin (+$5.25), free greeting card | Decorative gift bag with handles, 8.3 x 6 x 9 in box |
| Ratings |
Price history
$98.49$22.00
- The Indulgence Gift Set: lowest $98.49 on Oct 31 at Amazon.
- Bath & Body Works Gift Set: lowest $22.00 on Oct 31 at Poshmark; $28.00 on Nov 2.
Prices at every store
The Indulgence Gift Set
- Bend Soap CompanyCheck price at Bend Soap Company
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
Bath & Body Works Gift Set
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- MercariCheck price at Mercari
Specs compared
| Spec | The Indulgence Gift Set | Bath & Body Works Gift Set |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Boxed | Gift Set |
| packaging | keepsake ivory box | — |
| Gift box height | — | 8.3" (21.1 cm) |
| Gift box length | — | 6" (15.2 cm) |
| Gift box width | — | 9" (22.9 cm) |
| Body cream size | — | 8 oz/226 g |
| Fragrance mist size | — | 8 fl oz/236 mL |
| Candle size | — | 14.5 oz/411 g |
| Wallflowers refill size | — | 0.8 fl oz/24 mL |
| Hand sanitizer size | — | 1 fl oz/29 mL |
What reviewers say
The Indulgence Gift Set
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 525 ratings. Buyers say the goat milk soap calms itchy, sensitive skin within days and call the set a great deal. They also report it arrives beautifully packaged and giftable.
Pros
- Relieves itchy, sensitive skin within days
- Good value for the number of items
- Safe for eczema, gluten and nut allergies
- Arrives well packaged and ready to gift
Cons
- Sold only in 50-box minimums
- Contents list is unclear about chocolate items
Questions and answers
- Which is better for sensitive skin or eczema?
- The Indulgence Gift Set. Its goat milk soap, lotion, and bath are marketed for eczema and sensitive skin, and buyers report relief from itching within days. The Bath & Body Works set is fragranced with berries, champagne, and tangerine.
- Which is cheaper?
- The Bath & Body Works set, at $22.00 to $28.00 since October 31, 2026. No price is shown for the Indulgence set, and it requires a 50-box minimum order.
- Can I buy just one Indulgence Gift Set?
- No. The minimum order quantity is 50 boxes, so it suits weddings, corporate gifts, or group orders. The Bath & Body Works set sells as a single gift.
- Which is the better birthday gift?
- The Bath & Body Works set for a scented, celebratory gift with a candle and mist in a gift bag. The Indulgence set is better for a recipient who prefers unscented, natural body care.
- Does the Indulgence set include a card?
- Yes, a complimentary greeting card. You also choose a free Bend Soap Co. gift box or a silver tin for $5.25 more.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Indulgence set. It includes two full-size soap bars, a 150 g scrub, lotion, and bath, which cover many weeks of use. The Bath & Body Works cream is 8 oz and the mist 8 fl oz.