The Mahjong Line Botanical Mahjong Set vs Jonathan Adler Basketweave Mahjong Set

Buy the Mahjong Line Botanical if you want a playable set with hand-painted tiles, a carry bag and a rules guide. Buy the Jonathan Adler Basketweave if you want a lacquered velvet-lined box that looks good on a shelf and holds a set you already own. The Mahjong Line is the better game piece; the Adler is the better object. Owners of the Botanical praise the artwork and packaging; the Adler is known for its glossy finish and stackable box, not for its tiles.

• Choose the Mahjong Line Botanical if you want a complete, hand-painted set you can actually play and carry to a friend's table.
• Choose the Jonathan Adler Basketweave if you want a polished lacquer and velvet storage box for a set you already have, or a gift that reads as decor.