Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

The Net Return Simulator Series Bay vs Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit

Buy the Net Return Simulator Series Bay if you want a finished, freestanding bay that goes up in under 45 minutes without tools and holds up to 250 MPH ball speeds. Buy the Carl's Place DIY kit if you want a borderless floor-to-turf image and don't mind building the frame yourself. The Net Return's powder-coated aluminum frame and floating HD screen draw strong owner praise for build and easy assembly; Carl's Place is the more flexible, budget-minded DIY route with a basic polyester screen.

  • Choose the Net Return Simulator Series Bay if you want a tool-free, freestanding aluminum bay with a sound-absorbing floating HD screen and no framing work.
  • Choose the Carl's Place DIY Enclosure Kit if you want borderless floor-to-turf visuals and a build-it-yourself enclosure you can size to your room.

Prices

  • The Net Return Simulator Series Bay: $1,395.00 at Top Shelf Golf (checked today)
  • Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit: $999.95 at PlayBetter (checked today)
  • Difference: the Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit is $395.05 cheaper than the The Net Return Simulator Series Bay today
The Net Return
The Net Return Simulator Series Bay

The Net Return Simulator Series Bay

4.9(118 ratings)
$1,395.00at Top Shelf GolfChecked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Top Shelf Golf
Pros
  • Tool-free assembly in under 45 minutes
  • Aluminum frame rated to 250 MPH ball speeds
  • Floating HD screen absorbs sound and softens ball return
  • Rear and side valances darken the screen for a sharper image
  • Owners praise build quality and customer service
Cons
  • Launch monitor, turf, projector and computer sold separately
  • White polyester screen can smudge if handled carelessly
  • Needs 14 ft of depth or more depending on setup
  • Only three widths offered
Carl's Place
Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit (8′ × 8′ × 5′) with Standard Impact Screen

Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit

Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit (8′ × 8′ × 5′) with Standard Impact Screen

$999.95at PlayBetterChecked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit PlayBetter
Pros
  • Borderless floor-to-turf visuals from the cabled screen
  • Nylon enclosure catches stray shots and boosts contrast
  • Steel fittings, zip ties and bungees make tension adjustable
  • Multiple sizes to fit garages and basements
  • Simple, low-cost way into a DIY simulator
Cons
  • Frame pipe kit is an add-on, not included
  • Standard polyester screen is entry level
  • DIY build takes more time and effort than a push-button frame
  • No published ball speed rating

What separates them

The Net Return Simulator Series BayCarl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit
AssemblyTool-free Quick Color Connect frame, under 45 minutesDIY build with steel corner fittings, zip ties and bungees; pipe frame sold separately
ScreenFloating super white HD screen that absorbs sound and cuts reboundStandard 100% polyester screen with loose weave, aimed at beginners
FramePowder-coated black aluminum frame includedNylon enclosure only; pipe framing kit is an add-on
Image coverageScreen framed by rear and side valancesCabled screen gives borderless floor-to-turf visuals
Footprint8 ft wide, 8 ft 6 in tall, 3 ft 6 in deep; sits 6 in from a wall8 ft x 8 ft x 5 ft; deeper enclosure
Ball speed ratingRated to 250 MPHNot published
Size optionsThree widths: 8, 10 and 12 ftMultiple size options across the kit line
Room needsAt least 10 ft wide, 9 ft tall and 14 ft longFits garages, basements and man caves; check depth for your space

Price history

  • The Net Return Simulator Series Bay: lowest $1,395.00 on Nov 10 at OmniNova Home Systems.
  • Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit: lowest $999.95 on Nov 10 at PlayBetter.com.

Prices at every store

The Net Return Simulator Series Bay

  • Golfer’s CoveNew

    In stock

    $1,395.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Golfer’s Cove
  • EliteCore AthleticsNew

    In stock

    $1,395.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit EliteCore Athletics
  • OmniNova Home SystemsNew

    In stock

    $1,395.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit OmniNova Home Systems
  • Top Shelf GolfNew

    Availability unknown

    $1,395.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Top Shelf Golf
All 9 stores and price history →

Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit

  • PlayBetterNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $999.95Checked 5 h ago
    Visit PlayBetter
  • PlayBetter.comNew

    In stock

    $999.95Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit PlayBetter.com
  • Carls GolflandNew

    In stock

    $999.95Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Carls Golfland
  • Elite Sim GolfNew

    In stock

    $999.95Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Elite Sim Golf
All 12 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecThe Net Return Simulator Series BayCarl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit
Sport TypeGolf—
Width8'—
Height8'6"—
Depth3'6"—
Minimum room width10'—
Minimum room height9'—
Minimum room length14'—
Ball speed ratingup to 250 MPH—
Wall clearance6" from a wall—
AssemblyNo tools required—
Frame materialHigh gloss, black aluminum, powder-coated—
Screen typeFloating super white HD screen—
Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
SpecThe Net Return Simulator Series BayCarl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit
Setup timeunder 45 minutes—

What reviewers say

The Net Return Simulator Series Bay

  • 4.9 / 5118 ratings

Owners rate the bay very highly, praising the sturdy frame, the quality of the net and screen, and assembly that needs no tools. Many note the ball returns gently to the hitting spot and the enclosure works well in garages. Complaints center on the extras not included and the room depth required.

What people mention
  • AssemblyPraisedOwners say the push-button frame goes together quickly without tools.
  • Screen qualityPraisedThe HD impact screen is called durable and good at absorbing sound and killing rebound.
  • Ball returnPraisedBalls drop and roll back gently toward the hitting spot instead of bouncing hard.
  • Screen careCriticisedThe white polyester screen can smudge or stain if handled improperly.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a garage?
The Net Return fits a garage well because it is only 3 ft 6 in deep and sits 6 in from a wall, but you still need about 14 ft of length. Carl's Place is 5 ft deep and gives borderless visuals, so pick it if your garage has the extra depth.
Which is easier to set up?
The Net Return. Its push-button frame goes up without tools in under 45 minutes. Carl's Place is a DIY kit with steel fittings, zip ties and bungees, and you add a pipe frame separately.
Which screen is better?
The Net Return's floating HD screen absorbs sound and limits rebound, and owners rate it highly. Carl's Place's standard screen is a basic polyester weave meant for beginners; its cabled mounting does give a cleaner floor-to-turf image.
Is the Net Return worth stepping up to?
Yes if you want a finished aluminum frame, a quieter screen and fast tool-free assembly. Carl's Place makes more sense if you want to build it yourself and prefer borderless visuals.
Which handles fast ball speeds better?
The Net Return publishes a 250 MPH rating for its bay. Carl's Place does not publish a ball speed rating for this kit, so hard hitters have less to go on.
Do either include a launch monitor or projector?
No. Both are enclosures only. You supply the launch monitor, projector, computer and turf, though both work with popular simulator software and monitors.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • The Net Return Simulator Series Bay vs GolfBays SimBox
  • Carl’s Place C-Series DIY Enclosure vs The Net Return Simulator Series Bay
  • GolfBays SimBox vs Carl's Place DIY Golf Simulator Enclosure Kit (8′ × 8′ × 5′) with Standard Impact Screen

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best golf simulator enclosures for home garages
  • Best golf simulator enclosures for home setups