The North Face Himalayan Down Parka vs Calidez Down Parka

The North Face Himalayan Down Parka is the warmer, tougher option: 75/25 down-feather fill, a windproof and water-repellent shell, and a loose oversize cut that layers over a sweater. The Calidez Down Parka is the better wet-weather pick: a 10k/10k waterproof shell with sealed seams, a detachable hood and a regular mid-thigh fit. Owners rate the Calidez highly (4.8 from 53 ratings), while the Himalayan's reputation rests on its expedition heritage and durable build. Buy the Himalayan for deep cold and rough use; buy the Calidez for slushy city winters and rain.

• Choose the North Face Himalayan if you face real cold, want maximum loft and a roomy oversize fit for layering, and value a proven expedition-style build.
• Choose the Calidez if you want a waterproof, sealed-seam shell with a removable hood and a regular mid-thigh fit for wet, windy winters.