Rothy's The Penny Clog vs Dr. Scholl's Chill Out Slip-On Mule Clog

The Penny Clog is the better-made, more distinctive shoe: a washable ReVelvet upper, a contoured footbed and a grippy tortoise-shell rubber outsole, backed by a 4.9 rating from over 3,000 buyers. The Dr. Scholl's Chill Out is the lighter, more affordable-feeling option with a 1.125-inch platform wedge and a slingback strap, but its EVA and synthetic build is less durable and less supportive over long days. Buy the Penny Clog for all-day wear and a dressier look; buy the Chill Out if you want a low platform lift and a strap that keeps the mule on.

• Choose the Penny Clog if you want a washable, wide-toe-box clog with real arch contouring for long days on your feet.
• Choose the Dr. Scholl's Chill Out if you want a light platform mule with a slingback strap and a lower-profile look.