Theory Cashmere Crewneck Sweater vs Everlane The Cocoon Crew in Alpaca

Buy the Everlane Cocoon Crew for warmth without weight and a soft, non-itchy handfeel; buy the Theory crewneck for a cleaner, more polished look that layers under a blazer. The Everlane is a loftier alpaca-blend knit with a visible rib pattern, while the Theory is a finer, smoother knit with ribbed trim and a relaxed hip-length cut. Owners of the Everlane praise the softness and fit but report heavy shedding and a dry-clean-only care burden; Theory cashmere knits are generally regarded as well-made but thin, and pilling is a common complaint with lightweight cashmere.

• Choose the Theory crewneck if you want a smooth, understated sweater that reads dressy and slips under a jacket.
• Choose the Everlane Cocoon Crew if you want a soft, warm, itch-free knit with texture for everyday wear.