StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot vs Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

Buy the Thorogood 1957 if you want a USA-made boot with a Goodyear Storm Welt that can be re-soled and a moc toe that breaks in to fit. Buy the Ariat Activator if you want a lighter, more cushioned boot with a square toe and a pull-on entry system that suits long shifts on concrete. Owners of the Thorogood praise its durability and fit once broken in, but note the stiff start and narrow sizing. The Ariat is easier on the feet out of the box, though its cemented build is harder to repair.

  • Choose the Thorogood 1957 if you want a rebuildable, US-made leather boot for mud, grass and mixed outdoor work.
  • Choose the Ariat Activator if you want a cushioned, lightweight boot with a wide square toe and easy entry for indoor or concrete work.

Prices

  • Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: $294.99 at Tractor Supply Co (checked today)
  • Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: $209.95 at Blain's Farm & Fleet (checked today)
  • Difference: the Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot is $85.04 cheaper than the Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot today
Thorogood
Thorogood 1957 Series 8” Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots for Men

Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

Thorogood 1957 Series 8” Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots for Men

4.6(11 ratings)
$294.99at Tractor Supply CoChecked 3 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Tractor Supply Co

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Goodyear Storm Welt allows re-soling
  • Built in the USA
  • Waterproof breathable membrane
  • MaxWear90 outsole grips mud and grass
  • Steel toe protection
Cons
  • Stiff break-in period
  • Narrow width runs tight
  • Heavier than the Ariat
  • Lace-up only, slower to put on
Ariat
Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots

Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots

$209.95at Blain's Farm & FleetChecked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Blain's Farm & Fleet

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • FLX Foam midsole cushions long shifts
  • U-Turn Entry System speeds putting on
  • ASTM F2892 EH SR safety rating
  • Wide square toe gives room
  • Oil- and slip-resisting sole
Cons
  • Cemented sole is hard to repair
  • 11 in. shaft is bulkier under pants
  • Square toe is not for everyone
  • Imported

What separates them

Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe BootAriat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot
ConstructionGoodyear Storm Welt, can be re-soledCemented build, not designed for re-soling
Toe shapeMoc toe, closed round toeWide square toe
Shaft height8 in.11 in.
EntryLace-upLace-up with U-Turn Entry System
Midsole cushioningRemovable memory foam footbedFLX Foam midsole plus removable All Day Cushioning insole
Safety ratingSteel toe, slip-resistant outsoleASTM F2892 EH SR rated
OutsoleMaxWear90 slip-resistant, built for mud and grassOil- and slip-resisting
OriginBuilt in the USA with global componentsImported

Price history

$294.99$209.95
Nov 11Nov 21
  • Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: lowest $294.99 on Nov 21 at Tractor Supply Co.
  • Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: lowest $209.95 on Nov 11 at Blain's Farm & Fleet; $209.95 on Nov 21.

Prices at every store

Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

  • Tractor Supply CoNew

    In stock

    $294.99Free shippingChecked 3 h ago
    Visit Tractor Supply Co

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Prices and history →

Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

  • Blain's Farm & FleetNew

    In stock

    $209.95Checked 5 h ago
    Visit Blain's Farm & Fleet
  • AriatNew

    In stock

    $209.95Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Ariat
  • Tractor Supply CoNew

    In stock

    $209.99Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Tractor Supply Co

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 3 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecThorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe BootAriat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot
GenderMaleMale
Heel height6 in1.25"
Shoe size9.5 B—
BrandThorogood—
ColorBrown—
MaterialLeather—
Shoe widthNarrow—
Boot styleRugged—
Boot shaft styleMid-Calf—
Footwear featureSlip-Resistant—
Shoe closureLace-Up—
Boot shaft circumference12 in—
Show all 35 specsShow fewer specs
SpecThorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe BootAriat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot
Toe styleClosed Toe—
Shoe sole materialOutsole—
Insole materialMan Made—
Boot shaft height6 in—
Heel height styleLow Heel—
Shoe heel styleThick—
Clothing occasionWork—
Age groupAdult—
Shoe categoryMen's Shoes—
Boot shaft width style

What reviewers say

Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

  • 4.6 / 511 ratings

Owners rate the 1957 Series highly, praising comfort over long shifts, dry feet and the rebuildable welt construction. Complaints center on break-in time and weight.

What people mention
  • ComfortPraisedOwners say the memory foam footbed and wedge sole stay comfortable through long shifts.
  • WaterproofingPraisedWearers report dry feet in rain, mud and wet grass.
  • Break-inMixedSome say the leather softens within days; others find the first weeks stiff and uncomfortable.
  • WeightCriticisedSeveral owners call the boot heavy, especially with the steel toe.

Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

Owners of Ariat steel toe work boots generally praise the cushioning and all-day comfort, and the Activator line is well regarded for its waterproof build and easy entry. Common complaints are the weight of the steel toe and a stiff first few days of wear.

What people mention
  • ComfortPraisedOwners say the cushioned insole and FLX Foam midsole stay comfortable through long shifts.
  • WaterproofingPraisedWearers report dry feet in rain and wet job sites.
  • WeightCriticisedThe steel toe makes the boots heavier than composite-toe alternatives.
  • Break-inMixedSome owners find the leather stiff for the first few days before it softens.

Questions and answers

Which is better for standing on concrete all day?
The Ariat Activator. Its FLX Foam midsole and All Day Cushioning insole absorb more shock than the Thorogood's flatter wedge, which owners describe as firm until broken in.
Which lasts longer?
The Thorogood. Its Goodyear Storm Welt lets a cobbler re-sole it, so the upper can outlast several soles. The Ariat's cemented build is generally replaced rather than repaired.
Is the Ariat worth stepping up to over the Thorogood?
Only if comfort out of the box and easy entry matter more than repairability. The Thorogood wins on long-term durability and US construction.
Which is better for mud and outdoor work?
The Thorogood. Its MaxWear90 outsole is designed for mud and grass, and the taller lug pattern sheds dirt better than the Ariat's oil- and slip-resisting sole.
Does the Thorogood run narrow?
Yes. The listed 9.5 B is a narrow width, and owners report a snug fit. Try a wider width if you wear thick socks.
Which has the better safety rating?
The Ariat. It carries an ASTM F2892 EH SR rating covering electrical hazard and slip resistance. The Thorogood lists a steel toe and slip-resistant outsole without that full rating.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Thorogood 1957 Series 8” Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots for Men vs DynaForce
  • Thorogood 1957 Series 8” Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots for Men vs Ariat Men's Groundwork Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boot
  • Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots vs Ariat Men's Groundwork Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boot
  • Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Work Boots vs DynaForce

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best steel toe waterproof work boots
Regular
—
Model814-4200-GWP501—
ThemeGladiator—
Shaft height—11"
Toe shape—Wide square toe
Upper material—Full-grain leather
Lining material—50% recycled polyester lining
Waterproofing—DRYShield™ waterproof breathable construction
Safety rating—ASTM F2892 EH SR rated
Heel type—90° heel
Insole—Removable All Day Cushioning insole
Midsole—FLX Foam™ midsole
Sole—Oil- and slip-resisting sole
Entry system—U-Turn® Entry System