Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot vs Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot
Buy the Thorogood 1957 if you want a USA-made boot with a Goodyear Storm Welt that can be re-soled and a moc toe that breaks in to fit. Buy the Ariat Activator if you want a lighter, more cushioned boot with a square toe and a pull-on entry system that suits long shifts on concrete. Owners of the Thorogood praise its durability and fit once broken in, but note the stiff start and narrow sizing. The Ariat is easier on the feet out of the box, though its cemented build is harder to repair.
- Choose the Thorogood 1957 if you want a rebuildable, US-made leather boot for mud, grass and mixed outdoor work.
- Choose the Ariat Activator if you want a cushioned, lightweight boot with a wide square toe and easy entry for indoor or concrete work.
Prices
- Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: $294.99 at Tractor Supply Co (checked today)
- Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot: $209.95 at Blain's Farm & Fleet (checked today)
- Difference: the Ariat Activator Waterproof Steel Toe Boot is $85.04 cheaper than the Thorogood 1957 Series 8" Waterproof Steel Toe Boot today

