Tile Mate (2024) vs Apple AirTag
Buy the AirTag if you use an iPhone: it costs less at $22.40 at RELYmedia as of November 4, 2026, versus $24.99 at Amazon for the Tile Mate, and Precision Finding is far more precise than Bluetooth alone. Buy the Tile Mate if you use Android or need a tracker that works with both platforms, since the AirTag only works with Apple devices. The price gap is small, so ecosystem fit matters more than the few dollars.
Today the Apple AirTag costs $2.59 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Tile Mate (2024)
Choose the Tile Mate if you use Android, want one tracker that works on both iOS and Android, or prefer a sealed unit with a 3-year battery and no annual fee.
- Works with both Android and iOS
- Three-year battery, no replacements to buy
- Built-in keyring hole, no accessory needed
- IP67 water resistance
- No direction-finding arrows like Precision Finding
- Tile network is smaller than Find My
What separates them
| Tile Mate (2024) | Apple AirTag | |
|---|---|---|
| Works with Android | Yes, iOS and Android | No, Apple devices only |
| Finding precision | Bluetooth signal strength, ring from speaker | Ultra Wideband Precision Finding with direction and distance on U1 iPhones |
| Crowd network | Tile network, smaller than Apple's | Find My network, hundreds of millions of Apple devices |
| Battery | Sealed, 3-year life, not replaceable | Replaceable CR2032, over a year |
| Water and dust resistance | IP67 | IP67, dust resistant |
| Size and weight | 37.8 x 37.8 x 7.1 mm, 9 g | Coin-shaped, about 31.9 mm diameter, 11 g |
| Attachment | Built-in hole for a keyring | No hole, needs a separate holder |
Price history
- Tile Mate (2024): lowest $24.24 on Nov 1 at Amazon; $24.99 on Nov 4.
- Apple AirTag: lowest $19.00 on Nov 4 at Volshop.
Prices at every store
Tile Mate (2024)
- AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$24.99Observed at 12:05 PM
Also available at
Apple AirTag
- RELYmediaNew
In stock
$22.40Free shippingObserved at 12:09 PM - PC Richard & SonNew
In stock
$24.88Free shippingObserved at 12:09 PM - VolshopNew
In stock
$19.00+ $8.00 shippingObserved at 12:09 PM - eBayNew
Availability unknownSold by kt-electronics-1640 (99.4% positive, 12,100 ratings)Returns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.
$18.88+ $5.00 shippingVerified
Also available at
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- BrandsMart USACheck price at BrandsMart USA
- Sam's ClubCheck price at Sam's Club
Specs compared
| Spec | Tile Mate (2024) | Apple AirTag |
|---|---|---|
| Battery life | 3 years | Over a year |
| Water resistance | Water-resistant (IP67) | Water-Resistant |
| Product dimensions | 38L x 38W x 7Th millimetres | — |
| Item weight | 9 Grams | — |
| Connectivity technology | Bluetooth | — |
| Batteries included | Yes | — |
| Number of batteries | 1 Lithium Metal batteries required. (included) | — |
| Bluetooth transmission range | 76 m | — |
| Operating system compatibility | Android, iOS | — |
| Battery runtime |
What reviewers say
Tile Mate (2024)
Owners generally find the Mate reliable for ringing misplaced keys and bags around the house and like the long battery life. Complaints center on the sealed battery making it a disposable purchase and on the network-based finding being weaker than Apple's or Google's networks in some areas.
- Easy setup with the Tile app
- Loud enough ring for keys and bags
- Long 3-year battery life
- Holds up to rain and splashes
- Battery not replaceable
- Network finding less reliable in sparse areas
- No ultra-wideband precision
- Bulkier than some rivals for a pocket
Apple AirTag
Owners generally rate the AirTag as the most reliable item tracker for iPhone users, mainly for Precision Finding and the reach of the Find My network. Complaints center on the need for an extra holder and on the lack of true live tracking.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for Android users?
- The Tile Mate. The AirTag only pairs with Apple devices, so it is useless on Android. The Tile Mate works with both Android and iOS.
- Which finds lost items more precisely?
- The AirTag, on a U1 iPhone. Precision Finding shows an arrow and distance to the tag. The Tile Mate relies on Bluetooth signal strength and a ringtone.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Tile Mate, at about 3 years on a sealed battery. The AirTag's CR2032 lasts over a year but is user-replaceable, so it can keep going indefinitely.
- Is the AirTag worth it at $22.40 versus $24.99 for the Tile Mate?
- Yes for iPhone owners. It is cheaper as of November 4, 2026 and adds Precision Finding and the larger Find My network. Android users should pay the extra for the Tile Mate.
- Do either need a subscription?
- No. Both work without a monthly fee. Tile offers an optional premium plan for extras, and the AirTag needs no subscription at all.
- Can I use both at once?
- Yes. They use separate apps, Find My and the Tile app, so you can track an AirTag on your keys and a Tile Mate in a bag from the same phone.