Timex Easy Reader Watch vs Casio F108WH Illuminator

Buy the Timex Easy Reader if you want a leather-strap analog watch that looks at home with a shirt or a jacket, and you value the INDIGLO backlight for reading the time in the dark. Buy the Casio F108WH if you want a light, tough, low-maintenance digital watch for sport, work and rough daily use. The Timex reads as a dressier watch but its brass case and leather band wear faster; the Casio's resin case and band shrug off knocks and water splashes, and its 7-year battery claim beats the Timex's typical battery life. Owners of both rate them closely, around 4.5 to 4.6 out of 5.

• Choose the Timex Easy Reader if you want an analog dress-casual watch with a leather band and a backlight that lights the whole dial.
• Choose the Casio F108WH if you want a light digital watch that survives knocks, splashes and years between battery changes.