Tissot Lady Heart Women's Watch vs Casio Baby-G BGD10KH-9 Heart Watch

Buy the Tissot Lady Heart if you want a mechanical dress watch with real watchmaking inside: an automatic ETA-based movement, sapphire crystal and a see-through caseback. Buy the Casio Baby-G if you want a tough, fun quartz watch for sport and daily wear. The Tissot wins on materials and finish; the Casio wins on durability, water resistance and features. Owners of the Tissot praise the open-heart dial but note the leather strap and 30 m rating suit light wear, not swimming.

• Choose the Tissot Lady Heart if you want an automatic dress watch with sapphire crystal and a visible movement for work and evenings out.
• Choose the Casio Baby-G if you want a shock-resistant quartz watch with a stopwatch, timer and backlight for sport and everyday wear.