StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack Sweaters vs Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater

Buy the Charter Club if you want one sweater you will actually keep wearing: 100% cashmere, a clean crewneck and a shaker stitch that holds its shape. Buy the ToBeInStyle 4-pack only if you want volume and variety and accept that colors and styles arrive at random, all in size Medium. On build, cashmere beats an assorted acrylic-blend multipack on softness, warmth and longevity, and owners of cashmere crewnecks consistently report years of wear with proper care. The multipack wins on sheer count and the fun of a surprise, not on quality.

  • Choose the ToBeInStyle 4-pack if you want four size Medium turtleneck-style pullovers to rotate through and you don't mind random colors and styles.
  • Choose the Charter Club cashmere crewneck if you want one soft, warm, well-made sweater that layers under a jacket and lasts for seasons.

Prices

  • ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack Sweaters: $35.95 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater: $59.99 at Macy's (checked today)
  • Difference: the ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack Sweaters is $24.04 cheaper than the Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater today
ToBeInStyle
ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack High Neck Pullover Sweaters

ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack Sweaters

ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack High Neck Pullover Sweaters

$35.95at WalmartChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Four sweaters for the effort of one purchase
  • High neck adds warmth at the collar
  • Random assortment adds variety to a wardrobe
  • Simple care, generally machine washable
Cons
  • No control over color or style
  • All four are size Medium, so fit is fixed
  • Blend quality is unknown and may pill
  • High neck isn't flattering or comfortable for everyone
Charter Club
Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Crewneck Sweater

Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater

Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Crewneck Sweater

4.5(8 ratings)
$59.99at Macy'sChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Macy's
Pros
  • 100% cashmere, soft and warm without bulk
  • Shaker stitch adds texture and holds shape
  • Clean crewneck layers over a camisole or collared shirt
  • Neutral gray works with most outfits
Cons
  • One sweater, not four
  • Cashmere needs hand washing and flat drying
  • Pilling is possible under friction at the underarms
  • Crewneck offers less neck warmth than a turtleneck

What separates them

ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack SweatersCharter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater
MaterialAssorted knit blends, not specified per sweater100% cashmere
What you getFour sweaters in random colors and stylesOne sweater in a stated color
NecklineHigh neck / turtleneckCrewneck
Fit controlAll four are size Medium; no choice of color or styleYou pick the size and color you want
TexturePlain knits, varies by packShaker stitch texture
Warmth and softnessDepends on the blend; can pill and feel scratchyCashmere is soft, warm and lightweight
LongevityCheaper knits tend to pill and thin after a season or twoCashmere holds up for years with hand washing and flat drying
CareUsually machine washableHand wash cold, dry flat; more demanding

Price history

  • Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater: lowest $59.99 on Nov 18 at Macy's.

Prices at every store

ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack Sweaters

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by ToBeInStyle com INC.Returns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $35.95Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Walmart
Prices and history →

Charter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater

  • Macy'sNew

    In stock

    $59.99Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Macy's
  • LystNew

    In stock

    $69.99Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Lyst
All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack SweatersCharter Club Cashmere Shaker Stitch Sweater
colorOther—
actual_color4 Pack: Randomly Assorted—
clothing_sizeM—
sizeM—

Questions and answers

Which is warmer for cold weather?
The Charter Club cashmere is warmer for its weight and traps heat better than most blended knits. The ToBeInStyle high neck covers your neck, which helps on windy days, but the fabric itself is likely thinner and less insulating.
Which one lasts longer?
The Charter Club. Cashmere fibers are finer and longer-lasting than the acrylic and blended yarns typical of assorted multipacks, which tend to pill and thin after a season or two. The trade-off is that cashmere needs hand washing and flat drying.
Is the cashmere sweater worth stepping up to?
Yes, if you wear sweaters often. One cashmere crewneck gets more wear than four random knits you may not like, and it layers under a coat without bulk. Skip it if you want several colors at once or prefer machine washing.
Can I choose the colors in the ToBeInStyle pack?
No. The pack is a mystery assortment, and every sweater is size Medium. If you need a specific color or a different size, the Charter Club is the safer pick.
Which is better for layering under a jacket?
The Charter Club crewneck. Cashmere is thin and smooth, so it slides under a blazer or coat. The high neck on the ToBeInStyle sweaters can bunch at the collar.
Does the cashmere sweater pill?
Some pilling is normal on cashmere, especially under the arms and where a bag rubs. Remove pills with a fabric comb and wash it by hand to slow it down.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • ToBeInStyle Women's Mystery 4-Pack High Neck Pullover Sweaters vs CASHMERE SWEATERS PACK

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best cashmere sweaters in bulk