Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby vs Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford
Buy the Allen Edmonds McAllister if you want one dress shoe that works year-round and can be repaired for years. Its 360º bench welt, Dainite rubber sole and CustomCork insole make it the more durable and comfortable of the two for daily wear. The Tom Ford Elkan is a sleeker patent leather derby with a calf leather sole and Blake construction; it looks sharper for evening and formal wear but is less weatherproof and harder to resole. Reviewers of the McAllister praise the 65 last fit and long-term value, while owners of patent shoes like the Elkan note the finish needs care and shows scuffs.
- Choose the Tom Ford Elkan if you need a glossy black patent shoe for evening or formal occasions and want a slimmer, dressier profile.
- Choose the Allen Edmonds McAllister if you want a versatile wingtip oxford that handles rain, molds to your foot and can be recrafted instead of replaced.
Prices
- Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby: $644.00 at eBay (checked today)
- Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford: $195.00 at eBay (checked today)
- Difference: the Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford is $449.00 cheaper than the Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby today

