StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby vs Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford

Buy the Allen Edmonds McAllister if you want one dress shoe that works year-round and can be repaired for years. Its 360º bench welt, Dainite rubber sole and CustomCork insole make it the more durable and comfortable of the two for daily wear. The Tom Ford Elkan is a sleeker patent leather derby with a calf leather sole and Blake construction; it looks sharper for evening and formal wear but is less weatherproof and harder to resole. Reviewers of the McAllister praise the 65 last fit and long-term value, while owners of patent shoes like the Elkan note the finish needs care and shows scuffs.

  • Choose the Tom Ford Elkan if you need a glossy black patent shoe for evening or formal occasions and want a slimmer, dressier profile.
  • Choose the Allen Edmonds McAllister if you want a versatile wingtip oxford that handles rain, molds to your foot and can be recrafted instead of replaced.

Prices

  • Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby: $644.00 at eBay (checked today)
  • Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford: $195.00 at eBay (checked today)
  • Difference: the Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford is $449.00 cheaper than the Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby today
Tom Ford
Tom Ford Elkan Patent Lace Up

Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby

Tom Ford Elkan Patent Lace Up

$644.00at eBayChecked 6 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Pros
  • Glossy patent finish stands out for evening and black-tie-adjacent wear
  • Slim derby profile looks sharp with a suit
  • Calf leather upper and lining
  • Leather sole keeps the silhouette dressy
Cons
  • Patent leather scuffs show easily and need careful care
  • Blake construction limits resoling options
  • Leather sole offers little grip in wet weather
  • Less forgiving fit than a cork-bedded shoe
Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds Men's McAllister Shoe

Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford

Allen Edmonds Men's McAllister Shoe

$195.00at eBayChecked 6 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Pros
  • 360º bench welt and recraftable construction
  • Dainite rubber sole grips in rain and snow
  • CustomCork insole molds to your foot
  • Burnished calfskin develops a rich patina
  • 65 last is Allen Edmonds' most popular fit
Cons
  • Brogue wingtip styling is less formal than a plain patent shoe
  • Dainite sole is bulkier than a slim leather sole
  • Classic fit may run roomy for narrow feet
  • Burnished finish needs polishing to keep its look

What separates them

Tom Ford Elkan Patent DerbyAllen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford
StylePlain patent leather derby with a clean, formal lookWingtip balmoral oxford with brogue perforation and pinked edging
ConstructionBlake construction, harder to resole360º bench welt, fully recraftable by Allen Edmonds
SoleCalf leather sole, smooth and dressy but slippery in wet weatherDainite rubber outsole for grip in rain or snow
Upper finishPatent calf leather, glossy and prone to visible scuffsBurnished calfskin that develops a patina and hides wear
ComfortLeather lining with no cork footbedCustomCork insole molds to the foot over time
FitSlim dress profile, less forgiving across the instep65 last, Allen Edmonds' most popular fit; take your regular size
Weather useBest kept for dry, formal occasionsBuilt for all-weather wear
LongevityBlake-stitched, limited repair optionsRecraftable for full restoration

Price history

  • Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby: lowest $1,750.00 on Nov 21 at Nordstrom.
  • Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford: lowest $240.00 on Nov 21 at Poshmark.

Prices at every store

Tom Ford Elkan Patent Derby

  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $1,750.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Nordstrom
  • FWRDNew

    In stock

    $1,750.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit FWRD
  • farfetch.comNew

    In stock

    $2,550.00Free shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit farfetch.com
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownShips from Netherlands · duties may applyReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $644.00+ $35.00 shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 6 stores and price history →

Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford

  • PoshmarkNew

    In stock

    $240.00+ $6.49 shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Poshmark
  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $369.98Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $195.00Free shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit eBay
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $334.64Free shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • eBayCheck price at eBay

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 13 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecTom Ford Elkan Patent DerbyAllen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford
constructionBlake construction360º bench welt
upper materialCalf leather upperEuropean calfskin leather
heel height1.25 in—
lining materialCalf Leather lining—
sole materialCalf Leather sole—
finishPatent finish—
colorBlack—
Sole—Single layer, vegetable-tanned leather
Lining—Leather lined
Insole—CustomCork™
Last—65 footwear last
Closure—Lace-up
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecTom Ford Elkan Patent DerbyAllen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford
Style—Balmoral dress shoe
Origin—Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin
Recraftable—Can be recrafted
Fit—Classic fit: Take your regular size

What reviewers say

Allen Edmonds McAllister Wingtip Oxford

Owners of the McAllister generally praise its build, the patina the calfskin takes on, and the comfort of the cork insole after break-in. The Dainite-soled version draws particular approval for wet-weather wear. Complaints center on stiffness out of the box and the snug balmoral fit across the instep.

What people mention
  • Build qualityPraisedOwners say the welted construction and leather lining feel solid and last for years.
  • ComfortMixedThe cork insole molds to the foot, but several wearers find the first weeks stiff.
  • FitMixedMost take their regular size, though the balmoral closure feels tight over a high instep.
  • Dainite solePraisedWearers like the rubber outsole for wet pavement and winter without losing a dressy look.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a wedding or black-tie event?
The Tom Ford Elkan. Its glossy patent finish and slim leather sole read more formal than the McAllister's brogue wingtip and rubber sole.
Which lasts longer?
The McAllister. Its 360º bench welt lets Allen Edmonds recraft it, while the Elkan's Blake construction limits repair options.
Can I wear the McAllister in rain?
Yes. The Dainite rubber outsole is made for wet weather. The Elkan's leather sole is slippery and best kept dry.
Is the McAllister comfortable for all-day wear?
Yes, once broken in. The CustomCork insole molds to your foot. The Elkan has a leather lining but no cork bed, so it feels firmer.
Is the Tom Ford Elkan worth stepping up to?
Only if you need a patent formal shoe. For everyday dress wear, the McAllister offers more comfort, weather protection and repairability.
How does the fit compare?
The McAllister is built on the 65 last and takes your regular size. The Elkan has a slimmer dress profile that can pinch across the instep.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Tom Ford Elkan Patent Lace Up vs Christian Louboutin Greggory Cap Toe Oxford
  • Christian Louboutin Greggory Cap Toe Oxford vs Allen Edmonds Men's McAllister Shoe