Which set is better for a hot sleeper?

Both are 200-thread-count cotton percale, a crisp, breathable weave, so neither has a clear edge. Pick on price and pattern.

Do both fit a 15-inch mattress?

Yes. Both list a maximum mattress depth of 15 inches with deep pockets.

Is the Tommy Bahama set worth more than the Eddie Bauer set?

It adds Oeko-Tex certification and a larger review base. Whether that is worth extra depends on the price gap at your stores, which was not given for the Tommy Bahama set.

Which has more reviews?

The Tommy Bahama set, with 1,800 ratings versus 850 for the Eddie Bauer set. Both average 4.6 out of 5.

What is the lowest price seen for the Eddie Bauer set?

$55.27, recorded on November 7, 2026. The high over the same period was $60.99 on November 6, 2026.

Will these sheets shrink or pill?

Both are cotton percale with a 200 thread count. Wash cold and tumble dry low as directed to limit shrinkage and wear.

Tommy Bahama Pen & Ink Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Petite Floral Cotton Sheet Set

Both are 200-thread-count cotton percale sets with deep pockets for mattresses up to 15 inches, so the fabric and fit are close. The Tommy Bahama Pen & Ink set has more ratings (4.6 from 1,800) and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certification; the Eddie Bauer Petite Floral set has fewer ratings (4.6 from 850) and no listed certification. On price, the Eddie Bauer set has ranged from $55.27 to $60.99 since November 6, 2026; no current price was given for the Tommy Bahama set, so compare store prices before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.