Which is better for a hot sleeper?

The Tommy Bahama. It is 100% cotton percale, which breathes better than the Eddie Bauer's cotton-poly-flannel blend.

Which fits a thicker mattress?

The Eddie Bauer, at up to 16 inches deep versus 15 inches for the Tommy Bahama.

Are they the same thread count?

Yes. Both are 200 thread count and both use a percale weave.

Which has more reviews?

The Eddie Bauer, with 2,300 ratings against 1,800 for the Tommy Bahama. Both average 4.6 out of 5.

Is the Eddie Bauer set organic?

It is listed as organic. The Tommy Bahama set lists no certifications.

The Eddie Bauer, because of the polyester and flannel in the blend. The Tommy Bahama is plain cotton.

Tommy Bahama Vintage Map Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Animal Tracks Sheet Set

Both are 200-thread-count cotton percale sets with 4.6-star ratings, so the choice comes down to fit and material. The Tommy Bahama fits mattresses up to 15 inches deep and is 100% cotton. The Eddie Bauer fits up to 16 inches and blends cotton, polyester and flannel, which makes it warmer and less breathable. Buy the Tommy Bahama for a standard-depth mattress and pure cotton feel; buy the Eddie Bauer for a thicker mattress or a warmer sleep.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.