Blacksmith 18-Inch Tool Bag vs DeWalt TSTAK I Tool Case
Buy the Blacksmith 18-inch bag if you want one soft, roomy tote for hauling hand tools around the house or job site. Buy the DeWalt TSTAK I case if you want a rigid, stackable box that locks into a system and keeps small parts sorted. The Blacksmith is thicker 1680D oxford with a shoulder strap and a higher owner rating, but it is a single unstructured bag. The DeWalt is hard plastic with seven compartments, removable cups and dividers, and slide latches that connect to other TSTAK units; its smaller owner base rates it lower.
- Choose the Blacksmith 18-inch tool bag if you carry a mixed load of hand tools and want a soft, deep tote with a shoulder strap.
- Choose the DeWalt TSTAK I case if you want a rigid, stackable case with compartments for small parts and a system you can build on.
Prices
- Blacksmith 18-Inch Tool Bag: $25.99 at Walmart (checked today)
- DeWalt TSTAK I Tool Case: $34.99 at Fasteners Inc (checked today)
- Difference: the Blacksmith 18-Inch Tool Bag is $9.00 cheaper than the DeWalt TSTAK I Tool Case today

