Tops BOB Fieldcraft Hunter vs Benchmade Mini Bushcrafter 165BK

The Mini Bushcrafter is the better pick for most people: it is lighter, shorter and easier to carry and control, and CPM-S30V holds an edge longer than 154CM. The Tops BOB Fieldcraft Hunter is the choice for heavy batoning and big-hand work, with a 4.75-inch blade and a thicker, heavier build. Owners of both praise the G10 grip and the sturdy full-tang feel; the Tops is often called overbuilt for small tasks, while the Benchmade draws complaints about its small size for the money.

• Choose the Tops BOB Fieldcraft Hunter if you want a large, heavy fixed blade for chopping, batoning and camp chores where a 4.75-inch blade earns its weight.
• Choose the Benchmade Mini Bushcrafter if you want a compact, light carry knife for carving, food prep and general outdoor tasks.