Splendid Tori Cashmere Turtleneck vs J.Crew Wide-Rib Cashmere Turtleneck

Both are 100% cashmere turtlenecks, so the real split is fit and care. The Tori is a relaxed, drop-shoulder sweater with ribbed trims and a dry-clean-only label; the J.Crew is a classic-fit wide-rib knit that hits slightly below the hip and can be hand washed. Pick the Tori for a slouchy, oversized look and the J.Crew for a tidier fit that is easier to launder. Owners of both report softness and warmth typical of cashmere; the J.Crew's GCS certification gives more confidence about fiber sourcing, while the Tori's nylon-blend trims hold their shape at cuffs and hem.

• Choose the Tori Cashmere Turtleneck if you want a relaxed, drop-shoulder silhouette with ribbed cuffs and hem and you don't mind dry cleaning.
• Choose the J.Crew Wide-Rib Cashmere Turtleneck if you want a classic fit that covers the hip, a wide-rib texture, and a sweater you can hand wash at home.