Tough It Up Stretch Skinny Jeans vs Give It Time High Rise Ripped Skinny Jeans

Both are high-rise ripped skinny jeans in plus sizes, so the real split is fabric and fit. The Tough It Up pair is 98% cotton with low stretch, a 30-inch or 33-inch inseam and a 11-inch rise, so it holds its shape and suits taller shoppers. The Give It Time pair blends in polyester and rayon for medium stretch and a 28-inch inseam, so it feels softer and more forgiving but runs shorter. Owners rate the Tough It Up pair 4.2 out of 5 across 253 ratings; expect the cotton pair to feel stiffer at first and the stretch pair to loosen with wear.

• Choose the Tough It Up if you want a tall inseam, a higher rise and a cotton-heavy jean that keeps its shape.
• Choose the Give It Time if you want a softer, stretchier jean with a shorter inseam and full five-pocket styling.