Which is better for a weekend carry-on trip?

The Hardside Spinner. At 45 L and 8.1 lbs it is built as a carry-on, while the Compact Spinner is a 97 L checked bag.

The Compact Carry-On Spinner, at 97 L versus 45 L. That is more than double the packing space.

Which rolls more smoothly?

The Compact Spinner's eight MagnaTrac wheels self-align and track straight. The Hardside uses standard spinner wheels.

Is the hardside worth it if I mostly check bags?

No. Its advantage is cabin size and a hard shell. If you check bags, the Compact Spinner's capacity matters more.

Do both have TSA locks?

Yes. The Hardside has a built-in TSA lock and the Compact has an integrated TSA-compliant lock.

The Hardside at 8.1 lbs, versus 9.8 lbs for the Compact Spinner.

Travelpro Platinum Elite Hardside Carry-On vs Travelpro Platinum Elite Compact Carry-On

These are not the same class of bag. The Platinum Elite Hardside is a true carry-on at 45 L and 8.1 lbs, sized to fit most overhead bins. The Compact Carry-On Spinner is listed as checked luggage at 97 L and 9.8 lbs, so it flies in the hold, not with you. Buy the hardside for cabin travel and the soft-sided bag for longer trips that need checked capacity. No current prices were provided for either, so compare live store prices on Deal.ai before you decide.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.