Which is better for trick-or-treaters?

The Palmer mix, because every piece is the same milk chocolate in Halloween wrappers and the piece count is predictable. The bulk box works too, but you cannot tell how many pieces you get.

Which has more variety?

The bulk box. It mixes candy and chocolate brands, while Palmer is milk chocolate only in different shapes.

Which is better for a party with mixed tastes?

The bulk box, since it covers people who want gummies or sour candy as well as chocolate. Palmer suits a crowd that mostly wants chocolate.

Is the Palmer mix real chocolate?

It is sold as milk chocolate-flavored candy, which is a step below true chocolate in cocoa content and texture. Expect a sweet, mild flavor rather than rich chocolate.

Which lasts longer in storage?

Both keep for months in a cool, dry place, and individual wrappers protect each piece. The bulk box holds several brands with different best-by dates, so check each one.

Is it worth stepping up to the bulk box?

Only if variety matters to you. If you want one dependable chocolate treat for a bowl or bags, the Palmer mix does that with a clearer piece count.

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix vs Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box

Buy the Palmer Tricky Treats mix if you want one consistent product: solid milk chocolate in creepy shapes, individually wrapped, about 60 pieces per pound in a 5 lb bag. The assorted bulk box is the better pick when variety matters more than a single flavor, since it mixes candy and chocolate brands. Palmer is a mass-market chocolatey candy, not premium chocolate, and owners of both types of bulk mix report that wrappers and piece counts vary from bag to bag.

Choose the Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix if you want a single milk chocolate flavor in spooky shapes and foil wrappers for a candy bowl or trick-or-treat bags.
Choose the Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box if you want a mix of different candy and chocolate brands so there is something for every taste.

Prices

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix: $17.95 at Munchie Mayhem (checked today)
Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box: $34.99 at eBay (last seen Nov 8)
Difference: the Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix is $17.04 cheaper than the Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box at the latest prices (Nov 8 and Nov 10)

	Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix	Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box
Contents	One product: solid milk chocolate in creepy designs	Assorted candy and chocolate from multiple brands
Flavor range	Milk chocolate only	Mixed fruit, sour, gummy and chocolate types
Piece count	About 60 pieces per pound, roughly 300 in the 5 lb bag	Bulk box, piece count not stated
Wrapping	Every piece individually wrapped	Individually wrapped, brands vary
Theme	Halloween shapes and foil designs throughout	Halloween packaging, everyday candy inside
Allergens	Milk chocolate; check for milk, soy and possible nut cross-contact	Mixed brands, so read each item's label
Best use	Candy bowls and handing out one kind of treat	Parties and crowds with mixed tastes

Spec	Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix	Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box
Total weight	5 lbs	—
Pieces per pound	approximately 60 pieces	—
Chocolate type	solid milk chocolate	—
Designs	array of creepy designs	—
Packaging	individually wrapped	—

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix vs Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box

Prices

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix vs Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box

Prices

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix

Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix

Halloween Candy and Chocolate Mix Bulk Box

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Palmer Tricky Treats Halloween Mix

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent