Which is better for cold, wet weather?

They are close. Both use sheepskin and a topically applied water repellency treatment, not a waterproof membrane. The Classic Tall II covers more of the leg with its 10-inch shaft, which helps in slush and snow.

Is the Bailey Bow II worth the extra $63?

Only if you want the satin bows and the shorter shaft. Materials and soles are comparable, so the premium buys styling, not performance.

Which one lasts longer?

Expect similar lifespan. Both use twinface sheepskin and EVA outsoles. The Classic Tall II's taller shaft sees more wear and dirt, while the Bailey Bow II's satin bows can fray or stain.

Do they fit the same size?

Both are listed in size 5 and run true to size per UGG's sheepskin fit. The Classic Tall II listing is medium width; the Bailey Bow II is listed as 5M.

Can I wear either in rain?

Light rain is fine, but neither is waterproof. The treatment resists moisture and stains and wears off over time; reapply a sheepskin protector to keep it working.

UGG Classic Tall II Boot vs UGG Women's Bailey Bow II Boots

Q: Which is cheaper right now?

The Classic Tall II at $152 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, versus $214.95 at Amazon for the Bailey Bow II.

Both are UGG sheepskin boots with water-repellent treatment and Treadlite soles. The Classic Tall II is the better value right now: $152 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, versus $214.95 at Amazon for the Bailey Bow II. Pick the Bailey Bow II only if the fixed satin bows and shorter 8-inch shaft matter more to you than the $63 difference.

Today the UGG Classic Tall II Boot costs $62.95 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.