UGG Classic Ultra Mini vs UGG Tasman II

Buy the Classic Ultra Mini for a true ankle boot with a 17mm Twinface sheepskin upper, a rear pull tab and a Treadlite outsole that handles cold, wet sidewalks. Buy the Tasman II for a slipper you can wear outside: the sugarcane EVA sole is more durable and the braided collar is the signature look. Reviewers rate the Tasman II higher (4.6 from 2,600 ratings versus 4.0 from 106), and owners of both praise the warmth; the Ultra Mini draws complaints about sizing and the lower shaft letting in cold.

• Choose the Classic Ultra Mini if you want a short sheepskin boot with a real rubber-lug sole for winter walks and a taller 3.5-inch shaft.
• Choose the Tasman II if you want a slip-on moccasin-slipper for lounging and quick errands, with a cushioned sugarcane EVA sole and no laces.