Which is better for walking in snow?

The Adirondack III. It has a waterproof membrane, a lugged Spider Rubber outsole and insulation rated to -32C. The Tasman II has a flat EVA sole and a suede upper that soaks through.

Can I wear the Tasman II outside in winter?

For short, dry trips, yes. It is a slipper with a durable outsole, so it handles a driveway or a quick errand. It is not waterproof and has little traction on ice.

The Adirondack III is built from waterproof leather with a rubber outsole and should hold up to years of winter wear. The Tasman II's suede upper and EVA sole wear faster with outdoor use.

Is the Adirondack III worth stepping up to over the Tasman II?

Only if you need real winter protection. If you mainly want a warm slip-on for home and short errands, the Tasman II is the simpler choice.

Which is more comfortable for all-day wear?

The Adirondack III has a cushioned footbed and dual-density midsole for long walks, but it is heavy. The Tasman II is lighter and softer but has less support.

Do both run true to size?

Both are UGG women's styles and generally run true to size. The Adirondack III fits best with a medium-weight sock; the Tasman II is worn barefoot or with thin socks.

UGG Adirondack III Boot vs UGG Tasman II

These are different tools. The Adirondack III is a waterproof, insulated snow boot built for slush, snow and long walks in cold weather; the Tasman II is a slip-on suede slipper for indoors and short errands. Buy the Adirondack III if you need real winter protection and traction. Buy the Tasman II if you want a warm, easy-on shoe for the house and quick trips. Owners rate both well; the Adirondack is heavier and bulkier, the Tasman is softer and less protective.

Choose the Adirondack III if you face snow, slush or sub-freezing days and need a waterproof, lugged boot you can walk in for hours.
Choose the Tasman II if you want a plush slip-on for lounging, the office or quick errands in dry cold.

Prices

UGG Adirondack III Boot: $74.99 at eBay (last seen Nov 8)
UGG Tasman II: $21.00 at My Store (last seen Nov 11)
Difference: the UGG Tasman II is $53.99 cheaper than the UGG Adirondack III Boot at the latest prices (Nov 8 and Nov 11)

	UGG Adirondack III Boot	UGG Tasman II
Weather protection	Waterproof leather upper, waterproof membrane bootie and gusseted tongue	Suede upper, no waterproofing; fine in dry cold only
Warmth rating	200g insulation, 17mm wool lining, rated to -32C	Sheepskin lining for warmth, no temperature rating
Closure	Lace-up with non-wicking laces for a locked fit	Slip-on, no adjustment
Traction	Molded Spider Rubber outsole with lugged tread	Flat sugarcane EVA outsole, limited grip on ice
Weight and bulk	About 2.6 lbs per boot, 7-inch shaft	Light, low-profile slip-on
Ease of wear	Laces take time to put on and off	Slides on in seconds
Footbed and support	enerG Comfort System footbed, dual-density EVA midsole, removable insole	Cushioned sugarcane EVA footbed with moderate arch support
Indoor use	Too heavy and warm for the house	Designed as a slipper for indoor wear

Spec	UGG Adirondack III Boot	UGG Tasman II
Width	Width Medium	No information
Department	Women's	Women's, Women
Material	Fur, Genuine Leather, Genuine Suede, Nylon, Pol…	Suede
Color	Yellow, Chestnut, Black/Black, Mustard Seed, Th…	Gray
Closure Style	Lace-up	Slip-on
Season	Winter, Fall	Winter
Lining Material	Wool	Sheepskin
Support Type	Cushioning, Stability	Cushioned support
Outsole Material	Rubber Outsole	Sugarcane EVA
Upper Material	Waterproof leather	Faux Leather, Velvet, Wool, Suede, Sheepskin, L…
Lining	17mm UGGpure wool lining	Leather, Wool, Textile, Sheepskin
Outsole	Molded Spider Rubber	Rubber, EVA, Synthetic

Spec	UGG Adirondack III Boot	UGG Tasman II
Waterproof	Yes	—
Boot Style	Snow Boot	—
Style	Casual	—
Type	Boots	—
Insulated	Yes	—
Insulation Rating	200g	—
Weight	2.6 lbs per boot	—
Insulation	80% upcycled wool, 20% Synthetic	—
Boot Height	7-inch shaft	—
Closure	Lace-up	—

UGG Adirondack III Boot vs UGG Tasman II

Prices

UGG Adirondack III Boot vs UGG Tasman II

Prices

UGG Tasman II

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store