Which is warmer for winter?

The UGG Classic Mini II. Its upper and lining are 100% sheepskin, and it is built for fall and winter. The Dr. Martens has a leather lining and is listed for all seasons.

Which is better in rain and snow?

The Dr. Martens Buzz Strap Boot. It is listed as waterproof leather with a rubber platform sole. The UGG is only pre-treated to resist stains and water and is not Gore-Tex.

Is the Dr. Martens worth $63 more?

Only if you need the rubber platform sole, the strap closure and year-round leather. For warmth and a lower price, the UGG at $108.00 is the better value as of November 8, 2026.

Expect the Dr. Martens to hold up longer on pavement and in wet weather because of its rubber sole and leather upper. The UGG's suede and EVA sole wear faster with heavy outdoor use.

Which is easier to put on?

The UGG. It is a slip-on with no laces. The Dr. Martens uses laces plus a hook-and-loop strap.

Do both come in wide widths?

The UGG lists medium and wide widths. The Dr. Martens Buzz Strap Boot is listed in medium width only.

UGG Classic Mini II Boot vs Dr. Martens Buzz Strap Boot

Buy the UGG Classic Mini II if you want a warm, lightweight slip-on for cold weather at the lower price. Buy the Dr. Martens Buzz Strap Boot if you want a sturdier leather platform boot with a lugged sole and a strap closure. As of November 8, 2026, the UGG's best new price is $108.00 at athenabodywear-usa.com, versus $171.00 at Zappos for the Dr. Martens. That is a $63 gap, and the UGG also has far more buyer feedback: 4.5 from 5,500 ratings against 4.0 from 53.

Today the UGG Classic Mini II Boot costs $63.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.