UltraSoft Denim '90s Loose Overalls vs We The Free Good Luck Barrel Overalls

The We The Free Good Luck Barrel Overalls are the more versatile pick: a cotton-lyocell-linen blend with 1% elastane, adjustable buckle straps and a tapered barrel leg that moves with you. The UltraSoft '90s Loose Overalls are a stiffer, non-stretch cotton-Tencel pair with a high 12.75-inch rise and a wide 16.75-inch leg opening, so they suit shoppers who want a rigid, roomy vintage look. Reviewers of barrel-leg denim praise the shape but note the cropped 26-inch inseam runs short on taller frames, while non-stretch overalls like the UltraSoft soften with wear but break in slowly.

• Choose the UltraSoft '90s Loose Overalls if you want a rigid, high-rise, wide-leg vintage silhouette and prefer a button fly over buckles.
• Choose the We The Free Good Luck Barrel Overalls if you want stretch comfort, adjustable straps and a tapered barrel leg that works across more body types.