Universal Standard Seine Mid-Rise Skinny Jeans vs St. John's Bay Mid Rise Skinny Jeans

The Seine is the stronger pick for a true skinny fit with real stretch and a size range built for curvier bodies. The St. John's Bay is a lighter, easier everyday jean that many shoppers find flattering, but reviewers report inconsistent sizing, a stiffer denim in some washes, and a cut that reads more slim than skinny. Build quality is comparable at this level; the Seine's four-way stretch holds shape better, while the St. John's Bay wins on machine-dry convenience and a shorter ankle inseam.

• Choose the Universal Standard Seine if you want a genuinely stretchy mid-rise skinny that holds its shape and comes in extended sizes.
• Choose the St. John's Bay if you want a soft, ankle-length everyday skinny you can machine wash and tumble dry.