Which is better for a warm, shimmery look?

The Urban Decay palette, which is built around pink, bronze and orange shimmer. The Maybelline City Mini leans matte and neutral.

Which lasts longer through a long day?

The Maybelline City Mini is waterproof, which helps it hold up through sweat and humidity. The Urban Decay palette makes no waterproof claim.

Is the Urban Decay palette worth the extra money?

Only if vegan certification and the limited-edition pink and orange shades matter to you. Otherwise the Maybelline palette is cheaper and more versatile.

Which is better for travel?

Both are mini-sized. The Maybelline compact is the sturdier option and costs less to replace if lost.

Which works for evening looks?

The Maybelline City Mini, which is listed for day and night use. The Urban Decay palette is listed for day use.

Are either of them unscented?

No. The Urban Decay palette carries a Urban Decay fragrance and the Maybelline palette has a chocolate scent.

Urban Decay Lunar New Year Eyeshadow Palette vs Maybelline The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette

The Maybelline City Mini is the better buy for most shoppers: it costs $12.95 at Janets Closet as of November 7, 2026, versus $15.74 for the Urban Decay palette, and it has hit $7.95 on its price history. The Urban Decay Lunar New Year palette is the pick if you want a vegan, cruelty-free mini with pink, bronze and orange shimmer shades in a limited-edition format. Both are small pressed-powder palettes with buildable coverage, so the choice comes down to shade range and price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.